Case files · case 3 · part 2 of 3
Balancing the books
Part 2, the rebuild. Nothing to spend, and £843K a week to cut. The plan is simple: sell who doesn't play, promote who played on loan. It works one deal at a time, through the keepers and every clause the club could sell. Then Al-Hilal bid for Wharton, and the summer changes size. Five weeks after 153.8%, the books balance, and the question becomes who replaces him.
The same save as part 1: Scouting across nine leagues, captured to 1 June 2028, and the window from June to 1 September.
Three parts · one case
Eleven screens · one window
- 1The planSeven out, three up
- 2GoalEvery option beats ours
- 3In FMWhat they'd cost
- 4The salesAbout double their value
- 5The clauses£44.2M in a day
- 6Wharton£103M becomes £190M
- 7Balanced153.8% to 95%
- 8The successorAlready in the squad
- 9The keepersGoal, £178K a week cheaper
- 10Two attackersOne gone cheap, one kept
- 11The window£311.7M taken in
- ✓RebuiltAnd what part 3 measures
?Where part 1 left it
Cut first, buy later
Part 1 found the money going to players paid well and not playing, and U21s who played full seasons on loan in the same positions. The board passes on 15% of every sale, so the fee barely helps; the wage is the target.
The routine is the app first, FM second. Squad Vision finds the names and builds the plan; then each position gets a shortlist in FM, and FM's scouts check every name on it.
The brief
To cut: £843K a week on basic wages, £1.28M on FM's figure with bonuses.
To spend: nothing, until something is sold.
How: sell who doesn't play, promote who played on loan, and buy only where nobody in the club can do the job.
1Transfer plan · Plan
Seven out, three up, nobody bought
The first plan has no signings in it. Three positions are filled from the U21s, each one promoted if the player above him goes.
- −£697.5K a week: the seven sales' wages. The three promoted are already on the club's bill as U21s, so they add nothing.
- Saibari goes, not just Akhomach. With Soulé on 4,092 minutes at attacking midfield, Saibari was cover the club couldn't afford.
- Ibragimov's "in his league" is 23, against Amass's 70 and Obi's 60: the weakest of the three, and only cover.
| Rotation | Target | Fee | Wage | In his league |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Full BackIf Mitchell leaves | Harry AmassU21s · promoting | No fee | £16K | 70 |
| Attacking MidfielderIf Saibari leaves | Amir IbragimovU21s · promoting | No fee | £6.3K | 23 |
| StrikerIf Suárez leaves | Chido ObiU21s · promoting | No fee | £34K | 60 |
| To sell | Age | Value | Wage | Replacement |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Luis SuárezStriker | 30 | £43M - £47M | £195K | Promoting Obi |
| Ismael SaibariAttacking Midfielder | 27 | £71M - £78M | £150K | Promoting Ibragimov |
| Diogo DalotFull Back | 29 | £71M - £78M | £100K | none planned |
| Tyrick MitchellFull Back | 28 | £30M - £33M | £86K | Promoting Amass |
| Ilias AkhomachWide Attacking Midfielder | 24 | £23M - £26M | £80K | none planned |
| Ahmetcan KaplanCentre Back | 25 | £5.4M - £6.6M | £65K | none planned |
| Matheus DiasDefensive Midfielder | 25 | £3.3M - £4.5M | £21.5K | none planned |
The cards and the Sell panel set out as two tables. Later the plan gains a goalkeeper and Orozco, promoted as Dias's replacement; Akhomach comes off it.
2Scouting · Compare pinned
Every option beats ours
Vicario was the league's best keeper at Spurs, typically 93. At United he's been 71 and 68: mid-table, on £160K a week. No U21 or U18 is good enough to step in behind him, so the No. 2 has to be bought too.
- Scouting across nine leagues found keepers who all beat Vicario's 68, each ranked in his own league. 91 in Belgium isn't 91 in the Premier League, so goals prevented a game, a figure and not a rank, is the line that travels.
- Miszta has the best of it, 0.7 a game, and three seasons rising: 36, 69, 94.
- The fees are small, £0 to £6.8M, so both keepers can go: Vicario and Milinković-Savić, £235K a week between them.
| Goalkeeper | Club | Typical | Prevented / 90 | Value |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Guglielmo Vicario | Man Utd | 68 | 0 | £20M - £22M |
| Cezary Miszta | Rio Ave | 94 | 0.7 | £5M - £6M |
| Stefan Drljača | Antwerp | 91 | 0.4 | £0 - £50K |
| Toni Fuidias | Girona | 85 | 0.3 | £500K - £1.1M |
| Niklas Hedl | SK Rapid | 84 | 0.3 | £300K - £2.9M |
| Matthieu Epolo | Standard | 82 | 0.3 | £300K - £3.1M |
| Josep Martínez | Nott'm Forest | 80 | 0.1 | £4.6M - £6.8M |
| Kosei Tani | FC Twente | 76 | 0.4 | £3.8M - £5.6M |
| Tom de Graaff | FC Utrecht | 75 | 0.4 | £275K - £2.7M |
Each typical is Shot stopping, ranked among his own league's goalkeepers. Martínez is the only one measured in the Premier League beside Vicario.
Drljača and Martínez agreed moves elsewhere before the shortlist was made. The other six went on it.
3In FM · Shortlists · scout reports
What the app can't see
The app ranks on last season. FM's scouts rank on ability, and they know what each keeper would ask to be paid. The two orders don't match.
- Tani goes from the app's 5th to the scouts' 1st: B+, Superb. On FM's attributes he's ahead of Fuidias on every shot-stopping one: Reflexes 16 to 12, One on Ones 17 to 13, Handling 16 to 13.
- Miszta is near the top on both, the reassurance after one big season.
- They'd want £42K to £66K a week, not the £8.3K and £14.5K they're on. Still a fraction of Vicario's £160K.
| Goalkeeper | Wants a week | Scouts | App |
|---|---|---|---|
| Kosei Tani | £51.32K - £66.42K | B+ Superb | 76 |
| Matthieu Epolo · injured | £17.49K - £21.9K | B Quality | 82 |
| Cezary Miszta | £42.04K - £54.16K | B Quality | 94 |
| Toni Fuidias | £13.4K - £17.78K | B- Very Good | 85 |
| Tom de Graaff | £8.59K - £11.03K | C+ Good | 75 |
| Niklas Hedl | £47.69K - £60.93K | C- Practical | 84 |
Wants a week: the scouts' minimum and maximum wage demand. App: the Scouting typical, in his own league.
All six were extremely or incredibly interested: the club's name still sells, even when its budget can't.
4In FM · Messages
About double their value
The sales came in a rush from 20 June, and almost every one beat FM's own value. "No offers for Dalot", one message said; two days later Benfica paid £38.5M, two and a half times it.
- Vicario's is a loan to Monaco that becomes a £40M sale after 10 matches, with him an Important Player there. Until then United still pay half his wage.
- The board's share comes in at about 14% to 15% of what's paid up front. Suárez's £34M brought £2.9M: half of it is in instalments.
- Johnstone was kept "for now" on 29 June, and gone to Southampton a week later.
| Sold | To | Fee | Value, 1 Jun | Wage off |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Vicario · loan | AS Monaco | £40M after 10 | £20M - £22M | £160K |
| Milinković-Savić | Barcelona | £16.75M | £13M - £16M | £75K |
| Kaplan | Trabzonspor | £2.8M | £2.2M - £4.7M | £65K |
| Dalot | Benfica | £38.5M | £14.5M - £16M | £100K |
| Mitchell | Spurs | £22.5M - £30.5M | £13.5M - £14.5M | £86K |
| Suárez | Parthenope | £34M | £30M - £33M | £195K |
| Dias | FC Lorient | £2.9M | £2.9M | £21.5K |
| Johnstone | Southampton | £1.5M | £2.1M | £50K |
Eight messages, 20 June to 5 July 2028. The values are the plan's, from the 1 June capture.
The U21s sold too: McEvoy, Fredricson and McCormack among them, and Fitzgerald to West Ham for £19.25M, twice his value, on £5.5K a week.
5In FM · Clauses
£44.2M in a day
FM lets a club sell what other clubs still owe it: instalments, add-ons, a share of a player's next sale. On 4 July every one of them went, starting with the second half of Suárez's fee.
- £15.5M for Suárez's instalments, instead of £17.4M over three years: about 89p in the pound.
- £28.7M for twelve more, most of them shares of players sold years ago.
- Some may have been worth more later. Greenwood's 50% of his next profit went for £9.25M; at his £50M to £74M value it could have been £13M to £25M. With £95.7M of instalments due this summer, money now beat money later.
| Clause | Given up | Received |
|---|---|---|
| Luis Suárez | 6 instalments of £2.9M | £15.5M |
| Mason Greenwood | 50% of his next profit | £9.25M |
| Tyrick Mitchell | 2 instalments of £3.3M | £5.5M |
| Willy Kambwala | 20% of his next profit, and two add-ons | £4.375M |
| Facundo Pellistri | 45% of his next profit | £4.1M |
| Antony | a £3.5M final instalment | £3.1M |
| Alejandro Garnacho | 10% of his next profit | £1.2M |
| Four more | Vicario, Jackson, Fish, Ibrović-Fletcher | £1.21M |
| 4 July 2028 | "0 available to sell" | £44.2M |
Thirteen messages in one table. The board passed on about 15% again: £6.55M to the transfer budget, which reached £19.65M.
6In FM · Transfer offer
The deal that changed it all
On 1 July Al-Hilal bid £103M for Adam Wharton: the side's most-used player, 4,304 minutes, every one there was. It was a fair price, inside his £96M to £117M value, and his agent said he wanted to talk to them.
- The amended offer was £190M, and accepted. More than the other sales together.
- £27M reached the transfer budget, and the other 85% more than covered every instalment owed to June 2029.
- It cost the best player sold all summer: A+, four stars now and four and a half to come. Every other sale had been someone who didn't play.
| To Al-Hilal · Adam Wharton | |
|---|---|
| Fee, immediate | £84M |
| Instalments, 12 monthly | 2 × £9.5M |
| After 20 international appearances | £5.75M |
| Percentage of profit from next sale | 20% |
| First offer, 1 July | £103M |
| Accepted, amended | £190M |
His value £96M to £117M · £100K a week to 2031 · 4.5% solidarity to Blackburn and Crystal Palace, £8.55M.
7In FM · Club · Finances
Balanced, in five weeks
With the money in, about £34M of transfer budget moved across to wages. FM gave £670K a week of wage budget for it: roughly a year's wages for every pound.
- Wages 95% of budget, from 153.8% on 1 June.
- £60.4M in credit, from £176.7M in the red.
- The debt down £266.6M, and the 2030/31 projection a profit, not a £204M loss.
| Finances | 1 June | 6 July |
|---|---|---|
| Wages / budget | 153.8% | 95.0% |
| Wage budget available | (£1.3M) p/w | £155K p/w |
| Transfer budget | £0 | £12.67M |
| Overall balance | (£176.7M) | £60.4M |
| Remaining debt | £566.9M | £300.2M |
| Projection 2030/31 | (£204M) | £21.74M |
The wage bill fell £762K a week and the budget rose £670K. Both halves were needed.
8Scouting · Leaders
The successor was on the bench
Wharton's job was creating from deep: among our defensive midfielders he was 3rd on chance creation, finishing and crossing, and only 8th on ball winning. So Scouting looked for central midfielders on Chance creation, across nine leagues.
- Akliouche is joint 2nd of 687, on 96, level with Bernardo Silva and Cherki and behind only Foden. Wirtz, Güler, Olise and Musiala are below him.
- He started 14 games. Part 1 had him paid well and playing 40%. The best creator at the club was the one not playing.
- He moves inside, with Mainoo, Baleba and Orozco to win the ball beside him. Akhomach stays, to play across the three behind Šeško. No signing.
| # | Central midfielder | Club | Typical | Starts | Sub |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Phil Foden | Man City | 98 | 41 | 2 |
| 2 | Bernardo Silva | Man City | 96 | 23 | 29 |
| 2 | Maghnes Akliouche | Man Utd | 96 | 14 | 29 |
| 2 | Rayan Cherki | Man City | 96 | 12 | 21 |
| 5 | Michael Olise | Bayern | 95 | 29 | 2 |
| 6 | Arda Güler | Real Madrid | 94 | 45 | 6 |
| 6 | Harvey Elliott | Aston Villa | 94 | 32 | 0 |
| 9 | Florian Wirtz | Liverpool | 93 | 40 | 1 |
687 central midfielders ranked on their typical Chance creation figure, each among his own league's.
9In FM · Messages
Goal, £178K a week cheaper
Miszta signed on 11 July and Tani on 13 July, both near the bottom of what they'd asked. The third keeper is Byrne-Hughes, promoted from the U21s on £4K a week.
- Goal cost £285K a week on 1 June, and costs £107K now.
- Two keepers who could each start, where there had been a mid-table No. 1 and the league's worst No. 2.
- Their appearance fees are big, £11.5K and £14.25K a game. They count in FM's wage total with bonuses, not in the basic wage.
| Out | Wage | In | Fee | Wage |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Guglielmo Vicario | £160K | Cezary Miszta | £6M | £46K |
| Vanja Milinković-Savić | £75K | Kosei Tani | £7M | £57K |
| Sam Johnstone | £50K | Cameron Byrne-Hughes · U21s | — | £4K |
| £285K | £107K | £13M |
10In FM · Messages
One gone cheap, one kept
Two of last summer's attackers, both bought on the figures, ended the window going opposite ways.
- Saibari, the one nobody wanted, went to Sevilla on 6 August for £20.5M: a quarter of his £80M value, and bought for £56M a year before. The money was poor; the £150K a week off was the point.
- Real Madrid then bid £72M for Soulé, up to £92M, non-negotiable. The books didn't need it, and he was the attacking midfielder. It was turned down, with a promise to Soulé that a bid of £110M would be accepted.
- Soulé was bought at Roma on a value of £38M to £55M. A year on, Real Madrid offered up to £92M.
| Offer | Fee | Value | Wage | Answer |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sevilla for Saibari | £20.5M | £80M | £150K | Accepted |
| Real Madrid for Soulé | £72M - £92M | £71M - £86M | £190K | Rejected |
Selling Soulé would also have cost a £6.5M loyalty bonus and 5% in solidarity.
11Transfer plan · Progress
£311.7M in, £6M out
The plan's Progress tab as the window shut: six positions filled, five of them by promotion, and seven of eight sales gone. Only Vicario's is left, waiting on his 10th match for Monaco.
- Net spend +£305.7M: £311.7M taken in on the plan, and £41.03M more in 14 other sales.
- Wages −£671.5K a week on the plan, after Miszta and the promotions' small rises.
- On FM's screen on 1 September, the wage bill was 96.7% of budget with £100K a week left. The summer's instalments had taken the balance back to £22.3M in the red, still £154M better than June.
28/2913 of 14 done
Summer 2028 · 1 sale leftas of 1 Sep
Buying 6 of 6 filled
✓ Nothing left to buy.
Summer 2028 · 6
| Position | Filled by | Fee | Wage | Closed |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Full BackRotation | Harry AmassPromoted | — | £16.8K | 3 Jul |
| Central MidfielderFirst choice | Maghnes AkliouchePromoted | — | £145K | 7 Jul |
| GoalkeeperFirst choice | Cezary Miszta | £6M | £46K | 13 Jul |
| StrikerRotation | Chido ObiPromoted | — | £37K | 13 Jul |
| Defensive MidfielderRotation | Cristian OrozcoPromoted | — | £15K | 13 Jul |
| Attacking MidfielderRotation | Amir IbragimovPromoted | — | £20K | 1 Sep |
Selling 7 of 8 gone
To sell · 1
Guglielmo VicarioGoalkeeper · First Team
£21M · £160K p/w · Miszta signed to replace himSummer 2028 · 7
| Player | To | Fee | Wage | Left |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Tyrick MitchellFull Back | SpursOpened Full Back · Rotation | £23M | £86K | 30 Jun |
| Diogo DalotFull Back | Benfica | £38.5M | £100K | 30 Jun |
| Ahmetcan KaplanCentre Back | Trabzonspor | £2.8M | £65K | 30 Jun |
| Luis SuárezStriker | ParthenopeOpened Striker · Rotation | £34M | £195K | 12 Jul |
| Matheus DiasDefensive Midfielder | FC LorientOpened Defensive Midfielder · Rotation | £2.9M | £21.5K | 12 Jul |
| Adam WhartonCentral Midfielder | Al-HilalOpened Central Midfielder · First choice | £190M | £100K | 12 Jul |
| Ismael SaibariAttacking Midfielder | SevillaOpened Attacking Midfielder · Rotation | £20.5M | £150K | 31 Aug |
Not on the plan: 14 other sales, £41.03M in all.
Every sale on Signings ›
1 September 2028, the window shut. Tani was signed outside the plan, and Akhomach taken off it when Akliouche moved inside. The budget tiles, cut here, still held June's figures.
✓Rebuilt
Cheaper, and short of one player
The books balance. The squad is younger and much cheaper, and every position the summer emptied was filled from inside the club, bar goal. What it lost was Wharton, and part 3 is the season that finds out whether that mattered.
From 153.8% to 96.7%
The money: about £397M raised, from the plan's sales, 14 others and every clause, against £13M spent on two keepers. Wages from 153.8% of budget to 96.7%.
How: ten first-team sales, most above FM's value and several at double it. Five promotions from the U21s. Goal rebuilt for £107K a week. One bid nobody planned for, £190M for Wharton.
The squad: Akliouche in Wharton's place, Miszta and Tani in goal, Obi, Amass, Ibragimov and Orozco up from the U21s. Soulé kept.
What part 3 measures: whether a squad this much cheaper can stay in the top five, in the league and the Europa League, and whether the books stay balanced once the season starts.
Scouting, then the Transfer plan
Scouting found the keepers and the successor, the Transfer plan held the summer together, and FM's scouts and messages did the rest.