Case files · case 3 · part 3 of 3
Balancing the books
Part 3, the verdict. The summer cut the wage bill to 96.7% of budget and left the side without its most-used player. Three weeks into the season a new owner arrives and clears the debt part 1 found. Then the season answers the case's other question: did a squad this much cheaper hold up?
The same save as part 2: Premier League 28/29, captured to 1 June 2029, with Football Manager's finances and the finals.
Three parts · one case
Nine screens · one season
- 1The takeoverA tycoon clears the loans
- 2The finalsTwo trophies
- 3The leagueTop in September, 6th in May
- 4The team1st in attack, 20th passing
- 5Who playedThe cheaper squad
- 6The successor82% of the minutes
- 7GoalThe No. 2 became No. 1
- 8The promotionsRanked in the league
- 9The booksA year on
- ✓The verdictCase closed
?Where part 2 left it
Cheaper, and short of one player
The window shut with the wage bill at 96.7% of budget, about £397M raised and £13M spent. Wharton had gone for £190M, and Akliouche moved inside to replace him. Two keepers were bought, five players promoted from the U21s, and Soulé kept.
The season is the Europa League, not the Champions League: the Premier League has four places this time, and 5th last season wasn't one of them.
What the season measures
The books: do they stay balanced once the season starts?
The squad: did the players promoted and moved do the jobs of the ones sold?
The side: can it stay in the top five, in the league and in Europe?
1In FM · News · Finances
A tycoon clears the loans
On 24 September 2028 Diego Pérez, a Spanish investor FM calls a tycoon, completed a takeover. A consortium's bid had failed in May. The club was delisted, and a transfer embargo that had come in after the season started was lifted.
- The four old loans were gone, replaced by one of £95.91M over ten years. Repayments fell from £14.06M a month to £917K.
- The balance swung £177M in three weeks, to £154.9M in credit.
- The side went top the same week, with Ibragimov scoring twice in a 5-1 against Leeds.
| Debts and loans | 1 Jun 2028 | 25 Sep 2028 |
|---|---|---|
| Loans | 4 · £235M | 1 · £95.91M |
| Repayments a month | £14.06M | £917K |
| Net debt | £566.9M | £51.4M |
| Overall balance | (£176.7M) | £154.9M |
Landmarks: 24 September 2028, owner Joel Glazer leaves; new chairperson Diego Pérez takes over (Tycoon).
The summer balanced the wage bill; the owner cleared the debt. Two different fixes, a few weeks apart.
2In FM · the finals
Two trophies
The Carabao Cup at Wembley in March, the Europa League in Rotterdam in May. Both finals had someone from the summer's promotions in them.
- Amass was player of the match at Wembley, with two assists in a 3-2 against Nott'm Forest. Josep Martínez, the keeper who'd signed elsewhere before United's shortlist was made, was in Forest's goal.
- Šeško scored twice in the Europa League final and Obi got the fourth, 4-1 against Havre.
- The FA Cup went in the fifth round, 4-3 after extra time at Everton, with Akliouche scoring and assisting.
| Competition | Game | Score |
|---|---|---|
| Carabao Cup · final | Nott'm Forest, Wembley | 3-2 · won |
| Mainoo 7' (Amass), Soulé 57' (Amass), Šeško 59' (Mbeumo) · player of the match Amass 7.91 | ||
| FA Cup · fifth round | Everton (A) | 3-4 aet |
| Šeško 4', Soulé 50' (Akliouche), Akliouche 105' (Mbeumo) | ||
| Europa League · final | Havre AC, De Kuip | 4-1 · won |
| Šeško 5' (Hinshelwood), Mbeumo 15' (Šeško), Šeško 52' (Soulé), Obi 82' (Soulé) · player of the match Šeško 9.14 | ||
Tani kept goal in all three games. The Europa League win puts the club in the Champions League next season, and the board's new objectives say so.
3In FM · the final table
Top in September, 6th in May
65 points and 6th, five points off 5th. Last season's side finished 5th on 68, with a squad that cost far more.
- 89 goals, the second most in the league. Only Liverpool, on 105, scored more; Arsenal, the champions, scored 87.
- 50 conceded, the most of the top seven, and 13 games lost, more than any side above them.
- Arsenal won it on 78, 13 points clear of United.
| Pos | Team | L | F | A | Pts |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Arsenal | 8 | 87 | 40 | 78 |
| 2 | Liverpool | 9 | 105 | 58 | 77 |
| 3 | Man City | 9 | 84 | 44 | 71 |
| 4 | Spurs | 9 | 63 | 33 | 71 |
| 5 | Chelsea | 8 | 64 | 36 | 70 |
| 6 | Man Utd | 13 | 89 | 50 | 65 |
| 7 | Fulham | 14 | 60 | 55 | 58 |
| 18 | Sheffield United | 22 | 45 | 78 | 36 |
| 19 | Leeds | 19 | 42 | 72 | 33 |
| 20 | Sunderland | 24 | 24 | 78 | 22 |
Champions LeagueEuropa LeagueRelegated
4League comparison · Teams · Season change
1st in attack, 20th passing
On Football Manager's own team figures, the side was among the league's best going forward and its worst at keeping the ball.
- 1st on expected goals for and chances created, 2nd on goals per game behind Liverpool: 2.71 chances a match against the league's 1.71. Better than last season on every attacking line.
- 20th of 20 on pass completion, and 7th on goals conceded. Expected goals against was 4th and clean sheets 2nd, so the defending was better than the goals against say.
- It faded from December: chances created down from 3.18 to 2.71 a match, conversion from 17% to 15%, and goals conceded up from 0.95 to 1.32 a match.
| Capture | Chances a match | Conversion | Conceded a match |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 Nov 2028 | 3.21 · 1st | 17% · 4th | 0.92 · 4th |
| 1 Dec 2028 | 3.18 · 1st | 17% · 1st | 0.95 · 5th |
| 1 Jan 2029 | 2.95 · 1st | 15% · 2nd | 1.18 · 7th |
| 1 Jun 2029 | 2.71 · 1st | 15% · 2nd | 1.32 · 7th |
| 27/28, the season before | 2.38 · 2nd | 13% · 4th | 1.37 · 12th |
Each row is the season to date at that team capture, ranked among the Premier League's 20 teams. No team captures between January and June. Season change shows one figure at a time; the three are set side by side here.
5Squad comparison · Game time & form
Who played
The summer's moves were promotions and two keepers. The minutes show which of them carried the side, and which stayed in rotation.
- Three new faces in the first eleven: Tani every minute, Akliouche and Kharebashvili 82% each.
- Rotation, not starters: Ibragimov 46%, Amass 35%, Lacey 29%, Obi 26%. Orozco played 287 minutes and Miszta 270.
- Diomande broke his leg and missed five months; Heaven covered, from 33% to 53%.
Game time and form, 28/29 most minutes first · bar: minutes against the most any of ours played · in bold: the summer's signings and promotions
| Player | Squad status | This season | Apps · G · A |
|---|---|---|---|
| Kosei TaniGK | Backup | 5,340'100% | 59 · 21 clean sheets |
| Leny YoroD (C) | Regular Starter | 4,364'100% | 53 · 5 · 1 |
| Kobbie MainooDM, M/AM (C) | Important Player | 4,013'92% | 47 · 15 · 8 |
| Matías SouléM (R), AM (RC) | Important Player | 3,964'91% | 51 · 19 · 26 |
| Benjamin ŠeškoAM (L), ST (C) | Star PlayerConcerned | 3,837'88% | 49 · 39 · 6 |
| Saba KharebashviliD (RL), WB (L) | Regular Starter | 3,597'82% | 46 · 3 · 10 |
| Maghnes AklioucheM (RC), AM (RLC) | Impact Sub | 3,565'82% | 58 · 9 · 16 |
| Jack HinshelwoodD (RC), WB (R), DM, M (C) | Impact Sub | 3,076'70% | 53 · 3 · 7 |
| Amir IbragimovM (C), AM (RLC) | Breakthrough Prospect | 1,989'46% | 43 · 9 · 8 |
| Harry AmassD/WB (L) | Breakthrough Prospect | 1,513'35% | 33 · 2 · 5 |
| Chido ObiST (C) | Breakthrough Prospect | 1,113'26% | 38 · 5 · 2 |
| Ousmane DiomandeD (C) | Important PlayerConcerned | 1,049'24% | 17 · 1 · 0 |
| Cristian OrozcoDM, M (C) | Breakthrough Prospect | 287'7% | 17 · 1 · 0 |
| Cezary MisztaGK | Backup | 270'5% | 3 · 0 clean sheets |
14 of the 24, with the month-by-month columns cut. Also played: de Ligt 90%, Baleba 82%, Mbeumo 79%, Barcola 74%, Fisher 68%, Heaven 53%, Akhomach 42%, Lacey 29%.
6Player evolution · Against the league
The successor took the minutes
Part 2 moved Akliouche inside to do Wharton's creating. He played 82% of the minutes, up from 40%, and the figures held up: a little lower than the season before, still in the top fifth.
- Chance creation 95 to 88, among 133 central midfielders. Assists held at 0.4 a game, 5th of 120.
- 9 goals and 16 assists in 58 games.
- FM made him an Impact Sub in August, and he still played the fourth-most minutes in the squad.
| Chance creation | 26/27 Monaco | 27/28 | 28/29 |
|---|---|---|---|
| Minutes | 2,353 | 1,779 | 3,565 |
| Typical | 93 | 95 | 88 |
| Key passes / 90 | 2.4 · 7th | 2.6 · 15th | 2.3 · 24th |
| Assists / 90 | 0.3 · 6th | 0.4 · 4th | 0.4 · 5th |
| Expected assists / 90 | 0.3 · 4th | 0.4 · 2nd | 0.3 · 4th |
| Chances created / 90 | 0.6 · 3rd | 1.1 · 2nd | 0.8 · 7th |
Ranked among central midfielders, each season in its own league: 85 in Ligue 1, 128 and then 121 in the Premier League.
7League comparison · Players · Leaders
The No. 2 became the No. 1
Miszta was bought as first choice on one great season in Portugal, and Tani as the No. 2, the scouts' pick. It went the other way.
- Tani is 5th of 23 on Shot stopping, typically 72, on every minute of the season. Vicario was 68 the season before, on £160K a week; Tani is on £57K.
- Miszta played 270 minutes. Two keepers bought, one needed.
- Vicario's loan becomes the £40M sale on 1 July.
| # | Goalkeeper | Club | Mins | Typical | Wage |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | David Raya | Arsenal | 3,690 | 93 | £250K |
| 2 | André Onana | Burnley | 1,440 | 88 | £80K |
| 3 | Jonas Urbig | Spurs | 4,350 | 86 | £79K |
| 4 | James Trafford | Man City | 1,530 | 83 | £130K |
| 5 | Filip Jörgensen | Chelsea | 3,600 | 72 | £150K |
| 5 | Kosei Tani | Man Utd | 5,340 | 72 | £57K |
| 9 | Gianluigi Donnarumma | Man City | 3,870 | 51 | £500K |
8League comparison · Players · Leaders
Ranked in the league, not on loan
Part 1 judged the promotions on their loan seasons, a level down. Leaders ranks them among the Premier League's players at their position.
- Hinshelwood, kept as cover, is 1st of 101 defensive midfielders on ball winning. Kharebashvili is 3rd of 127 full backs.
- Lacey, a youth product, is 1st of 114 attacking midfielders on chance creation, Akhomach, taken off the sale list, 4th, and Soulé 6th: 19 goals and 26 assists from the player kept for £110M.
- Ibragimov, the weakest promotion on his loan figures, is 22nd of 114, with 9 goals and 8 assists. Obi is 21st of 90 strikers, behind Šeško, 1st with 39 goals.
| Player | Ranked among | On | Place | Typical |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Jack Hinshelwood | 101 defensive midfielders | Ball winning | 1st | 83 |
| Saba Kharebashvili | 127 full backs | Ball winning | 3rd | 84 |
| Harry Amass | 127 full backs | Ball winning | 29th | 66 |
| Shea Lacey | 114 attacking midfielders | Chance creation | 1st | 97 |
| Ilias Akhomach | 114 attacking midfielders | Chance creation | 4th | 93 |
| Matías Soulé | 114 attacking midfielders | Chance creation | 6th | 92 |
| Amir Ibragimov | 114 attacking midfielders | Chance creation | 22nd | 75 |
| Benjamin Šeško | 90 strikers | Finishing | 1st | 97 |
| Chido Obi | 90 strikers | Finishing | 21st | 70 |
Five Leaders screens, one row per player. Orozco, on 287 minutes, is unranked.
Soulé's Player window has his chance creation up from 61 to 92 in a season; his passing and defensive actions fell, to 17 and 13.
9In FM · Finances · Contracts & terms
Balanced, and creeping back
A year after 153.8%, the wage bill is 96.1% of budget, net debt is £0 and there's £181M to spend. But the new owner's money has already gone into wages.
- About £440K a week of rises since last June, and two Star Players where there had been none. Baleba went from £80K to £185K, Obi from £34K to £100K, Ibragimov from £6.25K to £57K, Barcola to £275K.
- The budget rose with them, £2.38M to £3.43M, so the bill is still under it.
- Paid well, not playing, again: Obi on £100K for 26% of the minutes, Diomande on £145K for 24%.
| Finances | 1 Jun 2028 | 1 Jun 2029 |
|---|---|---|
| Wages / budget | 153.8% | 96.1% |
| Wage budget available | (£1.3M) p/w | £135K p/w |
| Transfer budget | £0 | £181M |
| Overall balance | (£176.7M) | £317.9M |
| Net debt | £566.9M | £0 |
| Loan repayments a month | £14.06M | £917K |
| Projection 2030/31 | (£204M) | £611M |
Net debt £0 means the balance is bigger than the debt: £90.31M is still left on the takeover's loan, to 2038.
The first team's wage bill on Contracts & terms is £2.66M a week for 24, against £2.87M for 26 a year ago, and that still includes Vicario's £160K until 1 July.
✓The verdict
Case closed
Three parts, one year. The diagnosis found a club paying for players who didn't play and for two summers of signings. The rebuild cut the bill and lost its best player. The season says the cheaper squad held up, and won two trophies, but finished lower in the league.
The books balanced. The squad held up.
The money: wages from 153.8% of budget to 96.1%, the summer's doing. The debt from £566.9M to nothing net, the owner's. Two fixes, and the second could only clear a debt the first had stopped growing.
The squad: every player sold was replaced from inside the club or for a fraction of his wage. Akliouche took Wharton's minutes, Tani was a better keeper than Vicario, and Hinshelwood, Kharebashvili and Lacey ranked at or near the top of the league.
What the figures got right: Akliouche as the successor, Tani, the promotions, and Soulé, kept for £110M. What they got wrong: Miszta, bought on one great season and played for 270 minutes.
The cost: 6th in the league, with the league's best attack, its worst passing and a fade after Christmas.
Next season: the Champions League, through the Europa League, with £181M to spend, and a wage bill £440K a week heavier than the summer left it. The case that started with paid well and not playing ends with it coming back.
Game time, then Leaders
Squad comparison's Game time shows who carried the season, Leaders ranks each of them among the league's players at his position, and Season change follows the team month by month.
Balancing the books, from the start
Part 1 found where the money went, and part 2 cut it over one summer window. Case 2 took the same save into four competitions.