Case files · case 3 · part 1 of 3
Balancing the books
Part 1, the diagnosis. On 1 June the budgets for next season arrive, and there's no money: the wage bill is half as much again as the budget, there's nothing to spend on transfers, and the club is £176.7M in the red. Before anyone is sold, Squad Vision finds where the wages go, and who could do the same job for less.
The same save as case 2, a season on: Premier League 27/28, captured to 1 May 2028, and Football Manager's finances on 1 June 2028.
Three parts · one case
Seven screens · one bill
?Where case 2 left it
A good season, and the bill for it
Case 2 closed on 5th place, an FA Cup final and a Champions League quarter-final. The squad was deep enough. It had cost £336.5M in one summer, against £212M in sales, and much of that was bought on instalments.
Next season is the Europa League. The Premier League has fallen to 3rd in the coefficients, so it has four Champions League places, and 5th isn't one of them.
So this case asks a money question: who costs the most for the least? Every move this summer has to be paid for by another first.
1In FM · Club · Finances
Three figures
Football Manager's finance screens are full of figures. Only three matter here.
- The wage bill is 153.8% of the budget: £3.66M a week, with bonuses, against £2.38M. That's £1.28M a week over.
- The transfer budget is £0. Nobody can be bought until somebody is sold.
- The club is £176.7M in the red, and the projections say it gets worse: £190M in the red in 2029/30, £204M the season after.
| Finances · 1 June 2028 | |
|---|---|
| Overall balance | (£176,658,069) |
| Transfer budget available | £0 |
| Wage budget available | (£1.3M) p/w |
| Wage total (incl. bonuses) / budget | £3,660,594 / £2,380,804 · 153.8% |
| Projected balance 2029/30 | (£190M) |
| Projected balance 2030/31 | (£204M) |
Both Financial Fair Play tests are passed; that isn't the problem. The problem is the budget the board sets.
2In FM · Debts and loans · Clauses
Still paying for two summers
Behind the balance are two kinds of debt: the club's bank loans, and the instalments still owed on players already signed.
- The loans cost £14.06M a month, about £3.25M a week: nearly as much as the wage bill. Two of them end in 2029, and with them £10.98M of the monthly bill. This summer and next are the tight ones.
- £95.7M of transfer instalments fall due in July and August, and £226.8M in all, to 2031.
- £39.5M of it is for players who have already left: Kim, Ugarte, Mount, Dorgu, Højlund and Lammens.
| Loan | Remaining | A month | Until |
|---|---|---|---|
| Bank loan | £80.86M | £7.25M | Jun 2029 |
| Bank loan | £36.36M | £3.73M | Apr 2029 |
| Bank loan | £86.6M | £2.38M | Aug 2031 |
| Mortgage loan | £31.86M | £686K | Jan 2033 |
| Overall | £235M | £14.06M |
| Instalment due this summer | Owed to | Amount |
|---|---|---|
| Bryan Mbeumo | Brentford | £15M |
| Bradley Barcola | Paris SG | £11.66M |
| Benjamin Šeško | RB Leipzig | £11M |
| Leny Yoro | LOSC | £10M |
| Matías Soulé | AS Roma | £10M |
| Manuel Ugarte, gone | Paris SG | £8M |
| Rasmus Højlund, gone | Atalanta | £8M |
| Matthijs de Ligt | Bayern | £7.5M |
| Mason Mount, gone | Chelsea | £6M |
| Kim Min-jae, gone | Bayern | £5M |
| Senne Lammens, gone | Antwerp | £3.5M |
| July and August 2028 | £95.7M |
Already sold
From the Debts and loans screen and each player's Clauses. Wharton, Baleba and Hinshelwood's instalments fall due in June 2029.
3Squad comparison · Contracts & terms
Where £2.87M a week goes
Contracts & terms gives each player's wage, value and minutes, and a wage bill for those picked. Picked a position at a time, the first team's 26 players come to £2.87M a week.
- Basic wages alone are over the budget, by about £490K a week, before a single bonus. FM's £3.66M is the whole club with bonuses.
- The attack is the heavy end: nine forward players on £1.4M a week, nearly half the first team's bill.
- Nobody's contract ends this summer. Three end next summer, the same summer two of the loans do.
Wage bill, a position at a time each picked on its own · FM dates the capture 1 May 2028
| Picked | Players | Wage bill | A year | The most |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Goalkeepers | 3 | £285K p/w | £14.8M | £160K · Vicario |
| Full backs | 4 | £288K p/w | £15M | £100K · Dalot |
| Centre backs | 5 | £572K p/w | £29.7M | £220K · de Ligt |
| Defensive and central midfielders | 5 | £329K p/w | £17.1M | £100K · Wharton |
| Attacking and wide midfielders | 7 | £971K p/w | £50.5M | £220K · Barcola |
| Strikers | 2 | £425K p/w | £22.1M | £230K · Šeško |
Six screens in one table: each row is the wage bill tile with that position's players picked.
4Squad comparison · Contracts & terms
Paid well, not playing
Contracts & terms has a name for the corner that matters: paid well, not playing. Nine of the first team played under 30% of the season's minutes. Between them they're paid £735.5K a week, more than half of FM's overspend.
- Suárez, £195K a week for 903 minutes. Šeško played the rest, and scored 37.
- Dalot and Mitchell lost their places to Fisher and Kharebashvili, who are paid £102K between them. Both are Devastated, and Dalot is still valued at £71M to £78M.
- Kaplan and Johnstone didn't play a minute, on £115K a week between them.
- Three of the nine were bought last summer: Akhomach, Hinshelwood and Milinković-Savić, the No. 2 keeper FM calls First-Choice while Vicario, who played every minute, is Backup.
Wage bill
£735.5K a week£38.2M a year · the most £195K, Luis SuárezContracts ending
0 this summer · 3 nextThis summer: nobodyKey players, within two summers
1Milinković-SavićThis season
Under 30%of the most any of ours has playedTheir contracts and terms as at the latest capture · grouped by the summer each contract ends, soonest first · amber: a key player by FM's status whose contract ends within two summers
| Player | Age | Squad status | Contract | Wage | Value | This season |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Ends next summer · Jun 2029 3 | ||||||
| Vanja Milinković-SavićGK | 31 | First-Choice Goalkeeper | 30 Jun 2029 key14 months left | £75K p/w | £13M – £16M | 1,080'27% |
| Sam JohnstoneGK | 35 | Emergency Backup | 30 Jun 202914 months left | £50K p/w | £2.1M | 0'0% |
| Matheus DiasDM, M (C) | 25 | Fringe Player | 30 Jun 202914 months left | £21.5K p/w | £3.3M – £4.5M | 27'1% |
| Ends Jun 2030 3 | ||||||
| Luis SuárezST (C) | 30 | Squad Player | 30 Jun 203026 months left | £195K p/w | £43M – £47M | 903'21% |
| Diogo DalotD (RL), WB (R) | 29 | Regular StarterDevastated | 30 Jun 203026 months left | £100K p/w | £71M – £78M | 978'23% |
| Tyrick MitchellD/WB (L) | 28 | Regular StarterDevastated | 30 Jun 203026 months left | £86K p/w | £30M – £33M | 1,216'28% |
| Ends Jun 2031 3 | ||||||
| Ilias AkhomachM (R), AM (RLC) | 24 | Squad Player | 30 Jun 203138 months left | £80K p/w | £23M – £26M | 515'12% |
| Ahmetcan KaplanD (C) | 25 | Emergency BackupUnhappy | 30 Jun 203138 months left | £65K p/w | £5.4M – £6.6M | 0'0% |
| Jack HinshelwoodD (RC), WB (R), DM | 23 | Squad Player | 30 Jun 203138 months left | £63K p/w | £27M – £30M | 536'12% |
The nine picked together from the six position screens. Lacey, a youth product on £36K, played 20% and is left out: he's paid like a prospect.
5Squad comparison · Contracts & terms
Cheap, and playing every week
The same tab on the U21s and U18s finishes the bill. Basic wages across all three squads come to £3.22M a week; the other £437K of FM's £3.66M is bonuses.
- 46 U21s cost £300K a week, and £262K of it is on players out on loan. They're not where the money goes.
- Several played full seasons on loan, in positions where the first team has someone paid well and not playing: Amass at left back, Obi up front, Ibragimov at attacking midfield, Orozco in front of the defence.
- Even with no bonuses at all, basic wages are £843K a week over the budget.
First Team · 26
£2.87M a week£149M a yearU21s · 46
£300.3K a week£262K out on loan · 34 end in 2029U18s · 24
£52.9K a weekall trained at the clubAll three squads
£3.22M a weekagainst a budget of £2.38MFour U21s, out on loan this season: their loan club's minutes
| Player | Age | Contract | Wage | Value | This season |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Harry Amass D/WB (L) | 21 | 30 Jun 2029 | £16K p/w | £9M – £10.5M | 3,138' |
| Chido Obi ST (C) | 20 | 30 Jun 2030 | £34K p/w | £9.4M – £13.5M | 3,161' |
| Amir Ibragimov M (C), AM (RLC) | 20 | 30 Jun 2031 | £6.25K p/w | £10.5M – £12M | 3,532' |
| Cristian Orozco DM, M (C) | 19 | 30 Jun 2031 | £15K p/w | £7.6M – £9M | 2,723' |
The tiles are each squad's wage bill tile; the last adds them up. The four rows come from the U21s' own screens.
6Squad comparison · Statistics & metrics · Dials
Younger, cheaper, and no worse
Picking the First Team and the U21s together puts a loanee's season beside the player he'd replace, each ranked among our own at the position.
- Obi for Suárez: level or better on 5 of 7 dials, and 15 goals from 12.58 expected in 42 starts at Leicester. Suárez is the better finisher, just: 2nd of 12 to Obi's 3rd. £161K a week cheaper.
- Amass for Mitchell: a different left back. Mitchell wins the ball (78 to 70); Amass crosses and passes (56 to 44, 63 to 39). £70K a week cheaper.
- Ibragimov is the weak one: behind Saibari on 5 of 7. But his job would be cover for Soulé, who played 4,092 minutes, as Akhomach's was on 515.
- Dalot is still the better full back than Fisher on 4 of 7, on 978 minutes. He lost the shirt, not his football: £100K a week for 6 starts is about £867K a start.
| Strikers · rank of 12 | Obi | Suárez |
|---|---|---|
| Finishing | 3rd | 2nd |
| Chance creation | 6th | 6th |
| Movement and carrying | 6th | 10th |
| Aerial | 5th | 5th |
| Passing and progression | 6th | 7th |
| Ball winning | 8th | 7th |
| Crossing | 4th | 7th |
| Wage | £34K | £195K |
| Full backs · typical | Amass | Mitchell |
|---|---|---|
| Ball winning | 70 | 78 |
| Defensive actions | 36 | 45 |
| Crossing | 56 | 44 |
| Passing and progression | 63 | 39 |
| Movement and carrying | 50 | 45 |
| Aerial | 54 | 12 |
| Chance creation | 64 | 89 |
| Wage | £16K | £86K |
A loanee's figures are his loan club's: Obi's and Amass's are Leicester's, a level below. On attributes Suárez is still ahead on five of eight; he's 30 and Obi is 20.
7In FM · Finances · the board
15% of every sale
FM lets a manager move money from the transfer budget into the wage budget. So a sale ought to count twice: the wage it takes off, and the fee. The board's terms say otherwise.
- 15% of transfer revenue is made available. The other 85% goes to the club, and this summer it's already spoken for: £95.7M of instalments.
- A £75M sale puts about £11M in the budget. At 15%, a player's wage matters more than his fee.
- So cutting wages is the lever, and the fee is a top-up.
| The board's terms | |
|---|---|
| Transfer revenue made available | 15% |
| Next season's minimum guaranteed budget | £368K |
✓The diagnosis
Diagnosed
Seven screens, one bill. The club isn't paying too much for the players who play. It's paying for the ones who don't, and for two summers of signings, at the same time.
Paid well, not playing. And still paying for it.
The money: wages 153.8% of budget, £843K a week over on basic wages alone. Nothing to spend. £176.7M in the red, £14.06M a month in loans and £95.7M of instalments due this summer.
Where it goes: nine first-team players under 30% of the minutes, on £735.5K a week. The attack, on £1.4M.
What's there already: U21s who played full seasons on loan, on a fraction of the wages, in the same positions.
The brief for the summer: sell who doesn't play, promote who played on loan, and cut at least £843K a week. With only 15% of each fee to spend, the wages are the target, not the fees.
Part 2, the rebuild, follows the summer window: the sales, the keepers, the clauses, and the one deal that changed it all.
Contracts & terms, then the dials
Contracts & terms puts wages, value and minutes side by side for whoever you pick, with a wage bill for them all. Statistics & metrics then sets a loanee's season beside the player he'd replace.
Part 2, the rebuild
The summer window: nine sales, four promotions, two keepers, every clause sold, and a bid nobody expected.