Case files · case 2 · part 1 of 3

Four fronts

Part 1, the diagnosis. Man Utd finished 3rd and won the Carabao Cup. Next season is the league, the Champions League, the FA Cup and the Carabao Cup again: four competitions, and a game every three days. Is the squad deep enough? Squad Vision goes through it one position at a time, and the answers become a Transfer plan.

The same save as case 1, a season on: Premier League 26/27, captured to 1 June 2027.

Three parts · one case

  1. 1The diagnosisDeep enough?
  2. 2The rebuildThe summer window
  3. 3The verdictThe season

Nine screens · nine positions

  1. 1Goal5th of 24, every minute
  2. 2Full backsThe best ball winner, on the bench
  3. 3Centre backsOne wins everything in the air
  4. 4MidfieldTwo radars, one pair
  5. 5The no. 10One player, 32
  6. 6Left wingThree options, no starter
  7. 7Right wingThe backup was on loan
  8. 8StrikersTwo of the top three
  9. 9The planFive to buy, two to go
  10. ✓The diagnosisAnd the brief for the summer

?Where case 1 left it

A good season, and a harder one to come

Case 1 closed on 3rd place, 83 points and the Carabao Cup. The summer rebuild worked. That team played one game a week for most of the season. This one plays twice a week from August, and a squad that's good enough for one competition can still be too thin for four.

So this case asks a different question: not who's good, but who's behind them. For each position, who played, how much, and what the figures say about the player next in line.

Four fronts, one squad

26/27: 3rd in the Premier League on 83 points, 93 scored and 43 conceded. Carabao Cup winners. Out of the FA Cup in the semi-final, to Man City.

27/28: the Premier League, the Champions League, the FA Cup and the Carabao Cup, as holders.

How it runs: one position at a time, from the goalkeepers to the strikers, with a decision at each. The decisions go into the app's Transfer plan, and the plan is where this part ends.

1League comparison · Players · Leaders

Good, not the best, and never rested

Vicario came in as case 1's fix in goal, and on the season's figures he's still a good keeper: 5th of 24 on Shot stopping, typically 71. As a team we were 3rd on goals conceded, on Football Manager's own figures.

  • The three above him are at Liverpool and Arsenal, the clubs we're chasing. None of them is for sale.
  • Mamardashvili's 96 rests on 1,110 minutes as Liverpool's second keeper. Liverpool are the one team in the league that played two keepers, and on four fronts that's the model: a No. 2 good enough to play.
  • Vicario started all 48 of our games, every one of 4,320 minutes. Lammens started 2 and kept two clean sheets.
  • Lammens has been complaining about his playing time. If he leaves, Johnstone, unproven at 34, is the only cover. So the goalkeeper goes on the plan, but only if Lammens leaves.

The top 5 of 24, with Conceded and Penalties Saved left out. Below Vicario: Donnarumma 67, Martínez and Jörgensen 61.

2League comparison · Players · Leaders

The league's best ball winner, on the bench

Four full backs, two on each side. Leaders on Ball winning, with the Player and Playing Time columns opened beside each typical, shows how good they are and how much they played.

  • Dalot is 1st of 122, typically 94: 2nd on possession won and 4th on interceptions. Yet he started only 19 games, and came off the bench in 18.
  • Mazraoui started 30, on a typical 60, 35th. On Crossing it turns round: Mazraoui is 28th, typically 67, and Dalot 47th on 56. One defends, the other goes forward.
  • So right back gets a first choice: someone who wins the ball like Dalot and crosses better than either. When he's in, one of Dalot and Mazraoui can go.
  • Left back is covered. Mitchell is 3rd, 1st of 118 on tackles, and Shaw 14th, 1st on pressures and the better crosser. The one thing to watch is Shaw's age: 31, on £200K a week to 2029.

The top 5, then Shaw and Mazraoui; the rows between are cut, and so are the dial's own figures to the right.

3League comparison · Leaders · Compare pinned

One wins everything in the air

Pin the centre backs on Leaders, then Compare pinned sets them side by side, a radar each on one scale. On Aerial, with Diomande drawn behind the others, the gap is plain.

  • Diomande wins 91% of his headers, 1st in the league, and loses 0.4 a match, also 1st. De Ligt goes up for more, 7 a match, and wins 61%: he's 95th of 97 on headers lost.
  • De Ligt is the passer. On Passing and progression he's typically 72 to Diomande's 71, and 3rd on pass completion. Side by side, each covers the other.
  • Kim played 819 minutes, 9 starts, on £200K a week, and he's 30. On a set of my own, Ball playing defenders, built from eight figures under Your sets, Diomande is 2nd of 103 behind van Dijk, de Ligt 24th and Kim 55th. Kim goes on the sell list.
  • Behind them, Yoro and Heaven. Yoro played 426 minutes, blocked by Kim. Heaven spent the season on loan at Birmingham, in the Championship. Both need games, so they're 3rd and 4th choice, and the cup games are theirs. No centre back to buy.

Headers attempted has no better end; its pills aren't shown here. The positions given are the app's for this capture.

4League comparison · Leaders · Compare pinned

Two radars, one pair

The midfield plays two roles: a defensive midfielder, Baleba with Palhinha behind him, and a box-to-box midfielder, Wharton with Mainoo. Compare pinned on two dials, with Baleba behind every radar, shows why the pair works.

  • Baleba wins the ball: typically 78 on Ball winning, 5th in the league, 5th on pressures completed and 7th on tackles. On Chance creation he's 37.
  • Wharton makes the chances: 81 on Chance creation, 5th on expected assists, and 38 on Ball winning. The two shapes are almost the reverse of each other.
  • Each backup matches his starter's job. Palhinha is 3rd in the league on interceptions; Mainoo is 79 on Chance creation and 8th on chances created.
  • The one worry is Palhinha's minutes: 738, with 7 starts and 13 off the bench, at 31 on £180K a week. With four competitions he should play far more. Nothing to buy here.

5Leaders · the Player window

One no. 10, and he's 32

Click a name on Leaders and the Player window opens: every season captured, each ranked in its own league, with a ▲ or ▼ where a figure moved a band. Bruno Fernandes has two seasons, both at Man Utd.

  • He isn't slowing down. Chance creation went from 86 to 90, assists up a band, and Defensive actions from 31 to 48. On Leaders he's 9th of 165 central midfielders on Chance creation and 8th on Finishing.
  • The one dip is luck. On the same shots and the same expected goals, conversion fell from 16 to 14, and he went from 2.28 goals above his expected goals to 0.43 below.
  • The problem is the load. 3,348 minutes and 39 starts in 41 games, at 32, with nobody else in the squad who plays there like him. Mbeumo and Cunha rank above him on Chance creation, but one's a right winger and the other started 9 games.
  • So: an attacking midfielder, for rotation. Cover for Bruno now, and the player who takes over later.

6League comparison · Leaders · Compare pinned

Three options, and no starter

Barcola, Cunha and Rashford all play on the left, and all earn between £200K and £235K a week. Compare pinned against Barcola, the one who played, ranks them against the league's 160 wingers.

  • Barcola played the most and ranks the lowest: 3,779 minutes and 45 starts, but last of the three on Finishing, 53rd, on Chance creation, 18th, and on Crossing, 44th. He finished 0.67 below his expected goals. He does make chances: 6th on chances created, and 14 assists.
  • Rashford's figures are the best, 2nd on goals a match and 1st on expected assists, but they come from 798 minutes, and 25 of his 30 games were off the bench.
  • Cunha is the crosser: 6th on Crossing, and 4th on how many of his open play crosses find a man. He shoots from poor positions, though: 98th of 136 on expected goals per shot.
  • Rashford and Cunha both want more games. So left wing gets a first choice, and once he's in, one of them goes. Maybe both.

On Chance creation they're 82, 83 and 88; on Crossing Barcola 64, Cunha 85 and Rashford 77.

8League comparison · Leaders · Compare pinned

Two of the league's top three

Case 1's verdict said the finishing was fixed. A season later, it still is. On Leaders, Šeško is 2nd of 88 strikers on Finishing and Suárez 3rd. Haaland is 7th.

  • Suárez starts and scores: 36 starts, 21 goals, 28% conversion, 3rd. He scored 5.81 more than his expected goals, which may not happen twice.
  • Šeško gets the best chances: 1st on expected goals a match, and 1st of 92 on Aerial, where Suárez is 71st. But 34 of his 48 games were off the bench.
  • Behind them, Barcola, Mbeumo, Cunha and Rashford can all play up front.
  • Nothing to do here. The only risk is Šeško, at 24, wanting to start more.

9Transfer plan

Five to buy, two to go

Each position's decision goes into the Transfer plan, a screen of its own that can also pop out and sit over FM. A position is a card, by squad and by tier: First choice, Rotation or Backup.

  • First choice: a right back and a left winger. Each makes room: once he's in, one of Dalot and Mazraoui, or of Rashford and Cunha, can be listed. The Sell panel keeps both in view.
  • Rotation: an attacking midfielder, a right winger and a goalkeeper. The goalkeeper only counts if Lammens leaves, which is why To fill says 4, and 1 more if someone leaves.
  • Going out: Kim to sell and Lacey on loan. Kim's value, £40M to £43M, is already in Selling, and his wage is £200K a week off the bill.
  • No targets yet. Find ▸ on a card opens Scouting on that position. That's where part 2 starts.

The U21s and U18s have plans of their own, below the First Team; neither has a position this summer.

✓The diagnosis

Diagnosed

Nine positions, nine decisions, one plan. The case stays open until the season says whether the plan was enough. What the summer does about it is part 2.

Deep enough in the middle. Thin on the flanks.

Where it's deep: the strikers, two of the league's top three finishers. The midfield, a pair who complement each other and a backup for each. Centre back, once Kim's minutes go to Yoro and Heaven. Left back, where Mitchell covers Shaw. Goal, while Lammens stays.

Where it isn't: right back, where the better defender sat on the bench and neither crosses well. The no. 10, one player at 32. Left wing, three options and no starter. Right wing, where the backup was on loan.

The brief for the summer: a first-choice right back and a first-choice left winger, each letting one player go. An attacking midfielder and a right winger for rotation. A goalkeeper if Lammens leaves. Kim sold, and Lacey out on loan.

Part 2, the rebuild, follows the summer window: from Find ▸ on each card to the signings that close them.

The screens it used

Leaders, then the Transfer plan

Leaders puts a position in order on one dial, Compare pinned sets the players you pin side by side on radars, and every name opens the Player window. What you decide goes on the Transfer plan.

Next in the case

Part 2, the rebuild

The summer window: a target for each card, compared and signed, three positions nobody planned, and the plan closing position by position.