Case files · case 2 · part 3 of 3
Four fronts
Part 3, the verdict. Four competitions, sixty-odd games, and a board that set the lowest bar on every front. Squad Vision follows the season from 13th at New Year to 5th in May, a Champions League quarter-final and an FA Cup final, then asks the case's question: was the squad deep enough, and did the depth get used?
The same save as part 1 and part 2: Premier League 27/28, captured to 1 May 2028, and FM's results to 20 May.
Three parts · one case
Eight screens · one season
?From parts 1 and 2
Four targets, and a question
Part 1 asked whether a squad good enough for one competition could cope with four. Part 2 spent the summer making it two deep, ten signings and seven sales. Before a ball was kicked, the board asked what was achievable, and the answer was the minimum on every front.
So the verdict has two halves: the targets, which are the board's, and the depth, which is the case's own question.
The board's expectations
Premier League: qualify for the Europa League. Last season, 3rd.
Champions League: reach the league phase. The club vision: "Reach the UEFA Champions League proper".
FA Cup: reach the quarter-final. Last season, a semi-final.
Carabao Cup: reach the third round, as holders.
1In FM · the final table
5th, and the Europa League
68 points and 5th: the Europa League place the board asked for. The Premier League has fallen to 3rd in the coefficients, so it has four Champions League places this time, and 5th isn't one of them. Last season's side finished 3rd on 83.
- Liverpool finished 7th on 62, two places below. Brahim Díaz had chosen them in August because their squad was "much stronger". He wasn't right, and we beat them 2-1 at Old Trafford in April.
- Man City won it on 86, and took the FA Cup final too.
- 5th means the Europa League next season, a step down from the competition this side reached the quarter-finals of. The club vision was met for this season, not the next.
| Pos | Team | Pld | Pts |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Man City | 38 | 86 |
| 2 | Brentford | 38 | 75 |
| 3 | Spurs | 38 | 74 |
| 4 | Nott'm Forest | 38 | 70 |
| 5 | Man Utd | 38 | 68 |
| 6 | Brighton | 38 | 63 |
| 7 | Liverpool | 38 | 62 |
| 8 | Newcastle | 38 | 61 |
| 18 | Ipswich | 38 | 28 |
| 19 | Wolves | 38 | 26 |
| 20 | Crystal Palace | 38 | 25 |
Champions LeagueEuropa LeagueRelegated
2In FM · the fixtures
A final and a quarter-final
Every cup target was passed, two of them by a distance.
- Champions League: 4 won and 4 lost in the league phase, Celtic 6-3 on aggregate in the play-off, then Man City 2-0 over two legs, two clean sheets against the champions. PSG won the quarter-final 7-5 on aggregate.
- FA Cup: 9-1, 8-0, 4-2, 3-0 at Everton and 5-2 against West Ham at Wembley. The final went 3-2 to Man City: Šeško scored after a minute and again on 78, and an Akliouche own goal on 75 decided it.
- Carabao Cup: out 1-0 at Chelsea in the quarter-final, two rounds past the board's bar.
| Round | Opponent | Score |
|---|---|---|
| Champions League · target: the league phase | ||
| League phase | 8 games | W4 L4 |
| Knockout play-off | Celtic (H, A) | 2-0, 4-3 |
| Round of 16 | Man City (H, A) | 1-0, 1-0 |
| Quarter-final | Paris SG (A, H) | 1-4, 4-3 · out 5-7 |
| FA Cup · target: the quarter-final | ||
| Third round | Boreham Wood (H) | 9-1 |
| Fourth round | Watford (H) | 8-0 |
| Fifth round | Peterborough (H) | 4-2 |
| Quarter-final | Everton (A) | 3-0 |
| Semi-final | West Ham (Wembley) | 5-2 |
| Final | Man City (Wembley) | 2-3 |
| Carabao Cup · target: the third round | ||
| Quarter-final | Chelsea (A) | 0-1 |
3League comparison · Teams · Season change
13th at New Year
On 1 January the side was 13th, on 28 points from 21 games, typically 11th on the Attacking dial and 10th on Defending: trouble at both ends. From there it took 40 points from 17 games, more a game than last season's 3rd-placed side.
- The turnaround was the attack. By May the side was typically 3rd on Attacking and 2nd on chances created, behind only Man City on most figures. Man City were beaten 4-1, Arsenal 5-1 and Chelsea 4-0.
- The defence never moved. Typically 11th on Defending in May as in January, 14th on tackles won, 16th on pass completion. Goals conceded slipped from 3rd last season to 12th.
- Conversion traces the season: under the league average at New Year, 3rd by March, a dip in April around the West Ham defeat, 4th in May. Last season it was 1st all year.
| Capture | Conversion | Rank | Conceded a match | Rank |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 Nov 2027 | 12% | 9th | 1.42 | 11th |
| 1 Dec 2027 | 13% | 6th | 1.38 | 10th |
| 1 Jan 2028 | 11% | 9th | 1.33 | 9th |
| 1 Feb 2028 | 12% | 7th | 1.36 | 11th |
| 1 Mar 2028 | 14% | 3rd | 1.34 | 11th |
| 1 Apr 2028 | 11% | 10th | 1.31 | 10th |
| 1 May 2028 | 13% | 4th | 1.37 | 12th |
| 26/27, the season before | 15% | 1st | 1.13 | 3rd |
Each row is the season to date at that month's latest team capture, ranked among the Premier League's 20 teams. Season change shows one figure at a time; the two are set side by side here.
A team's figures are Football Manager's own, from the league's Team Stats page, so they cover league games alone: the 9-1 and 8-0 cup wins aren't in them.
4Squad comparison · Statistics & metrics
The depth sat down
Squad comparison's "football behind them" is the season to date across every competition. It answers the case's question, and the answer isn't the one part 2 bought for.
- Ten players passed 3,000 minutes. Soulé started all 53 games he played, Fisher 52 of 56, Šeško 51 of 55. On four fronts, one eleven played most of sixty games.
- The two backups bought for depth barely played. Kaplan, the fifth centre back: no minutes at all, as the fans said in July, "surplus to requirements". Dias: 27 minutes.
- Two rotation signings played under 600 minutes. Hinshelwood, 4 starts. Akhomach, 2: Barcola kept the left wing.
- Lacey, kept for depth instead of a loan, did more with 870 minutes than most of them: 4 goals, 7 assists, a 7.15 rating.
| Played most | Apps | Starts | Mins |
|---|---|---|---|
| Adam Wharton | 57 | 51 | 4,304 |
| Kellen Fisher | 56 | 52 | 4,253 |
| Bradley Barcola | 54 | 49 | 4,215 |
| Benjamin Šeško | 55 | 51 | 4,181 |
| Matías Soulé | 53 | 53 | 4,092 |
| Guglielmo Vicario | 45 | 45 | 4,050 |
| Saba Kharebashvili | 48 | 46 | 3,689 |
| Matthijs de Ligt | 50 | 39 | 3,673 |
| Ousmane Diomande | 40 | 39 | 3,326 |
| Kobbie Mainoo | 52 | 30 | 3,093 |
| The depth | Apps | Starts | Mins |
|---|---|---|---|
| Ismael Saibari | 36 | 16 | 1,759 |
| Maghnes Akliouche | 40 | 14 | 1,717 |
| Vanja Milinković-Savić | 12 | 12 | 1,080 |
| Shea Lacey | 26 | 7 | 870 |
| Jack Hinshelwood | 23 | 4 | 536 |
| Ilias Akhomach | 19 | 2 | 515 |
| Matheus Dias | 2 | 0 | 27 |
| Ahmetcan Kaplan | 0 | 0 | 0 |
In bold: signed this summer. Every competition, to 1 May 2028.
5The Player window · season on season
Ten signings, by value
Each new player's window sets this season beside the one he was bought on, each ranked in its own league. Some went up, some went down, and the minutes explain a lot of both.
- Akliouche did best, on bench minutes. Better than at Monaco on Chance creation and much better on Finishing, 2nd of 100 Premier League attacking midfielders on creating, and worth £82M to £90M.
- Kharebashvili, the one the app couldn't see, is worth twice his fee at 19.
- Soulé, the marquee, fell on almost every dial. Chance creation 92 to 61 and Passing and progression 80 to 25, starting every game. His goals held, 16 of them, and his value still rose.
- Akhomach and Hinshelwood lost value on fewer than 600 minutes each.
- Passing and progression fell for nearly all of them, from abroad and from Norwich alike. With the side 16th on pass completion, that looks like how the team plays, not the players.
| Signing | Fee | Value now | Mins | One dial, then and now |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Maghnes Akliouche | £56M | £82M - £90M | 1,717 | Finishing 60 → 74 |
| Saba Kharebashvili | £15.5M | £29M - £35M | 3,689 | Crossing 88, first season captured |
| Matías Soulé | £55M, up to £65M | £79M - £95M | 4,092 | Chance creation 92 → 61 |
| Ismael Saibari | £56M | £71M - £78M | 1,759 | Finishing 78 → 50 |
| Kellen Fisher | £31M | £27M - £30M | 4,253 | Ball winning 77 → 69 |
| Vanja Milinković-Savić | £6M, up to £9.5M | £13M - £16M | 1,080 | Shot stopping 97 → 18 |
| Jack Hinshelwood | £40M, up to £45M | £27M - £30M | 536 | Ball winning 80 → 60 |
| Ilias Akhomach | £43M | £23M - £26M | 515 | Finishing 78 → 34 |
| Matheus Dias | £4.5M, up to £6.25M | – | 27 | – |
| Ahmetcan Kaplan | £12.75M | – | 0 | – |
Then: the season he was bought on, in his old league. Now: 27/28, among the Premier League's players at his position.
6Scouting · Compare pinned
Shaw's half, at 19
Part 1 described left back as two halves: Mitchell the better defender, Shaw the better crosser. Shaw went to Roma in August, and the 19-year-old bought to replace him took the shirt, 46 starts to Mitchell's 11, and started the FA Cup final.
- On Ball winning, Mitchell is still the better defender, 1st of 104 full backs on tackles, though Kharebashvili is 1st on interceptions and 2nd on possession won.
- On Crossing it isn't close: 87 to 59. A quarter of Kharebashvili's crosses find a man, 7th of 75, against 15% for Mitchell.
Compared against
⠿Tyrick Mitchell First Team✕
Typical 83
⠿Saba Kharebashvili First Team✕
Typical 80
Tackles Completed per 90
4.41001st of 104
3.18911th of 104
Tackle Completion Ratio
754752nd of 103
786633rd of 103
Key Tackles per 90
0.27217th of 104
0.14044th of 104
Interceptions per 90
4.28714th of 104
4.7991st of 104
Possession Won per 90
13955th of 104
14.4992nd of 104
Pressures Completed per 90
3.9983rd of 104
3.38812th of 104
Pressures Attempted per 90 no better end
13.4965th of 104
12.2928th of 104
Compared against
⠿Tyrick Mitchell First Team✕
Typical 59
⠿Saba Kharebashvili First Team✕
Typical 87
Crosses Completed per 90
0.77227th of 104
18315th of 104
Crosses Attempted per 90 no better end
4.97328th of 104
46734th of 104
Crosses Completed Ratio
154838th of 75
26917th of 75
Open Play Crosses Completion Percentage
153844th of 73
26889th of 73
Open Play Crosses Completed per 90
0.77822nd of 104
18811th of 104
Open Play Crosses Attempted per 90
4.98516th of 104
47922nd of 104
7Scouting · Compare pinned
The upgrade that wasn't
Milinković-Savić was signed as a better shot stopper than Vicario: 1st of 23 in Serie A on goals prevented. In the Premier League he was 24th of 25.
- He played 12 games, all starts, and let in 0.4 goals a game more than the shots he faced would predict. Vicario, part 1's keeper who never rested, played 45 and was level with expectation.
- Lammens finally went in January, to Wolves for £6M, a seventh of his £44M June value. Wolves were relegated.
Compared against
⠿Guglielmo Vicario First Team✕
Typical 58
⠿Vanja Milinković-Savić First Team✕
Typical 18
Save Percentage
795810th of 25
73823rd of 25
Expected Save Percentage no better end
87569th of 25
87569th of 25
Saves per 90 no better end
4489th of 25
31419th of 25
Expected Goals Prevented per 90
05610th of 25
−0.4424th of 25
Clean Sheets per 90
0.3628th of 25
0.11618th of 25
Conceded per 90 less is better
1.35411th of 25
1.44414th of 25
Penalties Saved Ratio
100Not ranked
0Not ranked
8The Player window · season on season
Barcola, Suárez, Šeško
The three forwards part 1 judged, a season on.
- Barcola got better. Part 1 put him among "three options, and no starter" on 59 for Finishing. He went to 71, scored 16, made 15 and was player of the match nine times, the squad's best rating. Akhomach, bought to start ahead of him, didn't.
- Suárez didn't lose his finishing, he lost his place. 89 on Finishing against 90, 8 goals from 8.18 expected, on 903 minutes. At New Year he had none.
- Šeško scored 37, about 12 more than his expected goals, and both in the final.
| Mins | Goals | Assists | Finishing | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Barcola, 26/27 | 3,779 | 11 | 14 | 59 |
| Barcola, 27/28 | 4,215 | 16 | 15 | 71 |
| Suárez, 26/27 | 2,896 | 21 | 3 | 90 |
| Suárez, 27/28 | 903 | 8 | 0 | 89 |
| Šeško, 27/28 | 4,181 | 37 | 7 | – |
Goals and assists across every competition; Finishing is the dial's typical, among the league's players at his position.
✓The verdict
Case closed
Three parts, one season. The diagnosis asked whether the squad was deep enough for four fronts. The rebuild made it two deep. The season says the depth was there, and that the side won with its first eleven anyway.
Every target met. The depth sat on the bench.
The targets: all four. 5th in the league, the Europa League place the board set as its target. A Champions League quarter-final, past Man City. An FA Cup final, lost 3-2 to them. A Carabao Cup quarter-final.
The depth: bought, and barely used. Kaplan didn't play, Dias played 27 minutes, Hinshelwood and Akhomach fewer than 600 each. Ten players passed 3,000 minutes. The bench players' figures, Akliouche's above all, say they should have played more.
What the figures got right: Fisher and Kharebashvili at full back, Akliouche, Šeško. What they got wrong: Milinković-Savić, whose Serie A numbers didn't travel, and Barcola, who got better than the season he was judged on.
What they couldn't see: the reasons that decided the summer, rival clubs, wages, wanting to start, and a goalkeeper's form in a new league. Every one of them was in FM, not on a dial.
Next season: the Europa League, with a squad younger and £603.5K a week cheaper than the one that won the Carabao Cup, and the same question: who plays when it's three games a week?
A final thought: an FA Cup final, a Champions League quarter-final and a Carabao Cup quarter-final, deep runs in every competition, and back in the top five. From 13th in January, that's a successful season.
Squad comparison, then the Player window
Squad comparison sets your players' seasons side by side, minutes to metrics. League comparison's Season change follows a team figure month by month against the season before. The Player window lines up a player's seasons, each ranked in its own league.
Four fronts, from the start
Part 1 diagnosed a squad for four competitions, and part 2 rebuilt it over a summer window. Case 1 took the same save from 14th to 3rd.