Case files · case 2 · part 2 of 3

Four fronts

Part 2, the rebuild. The diagnosis left five positions on the Transfer plan. Over the summer window each one goes from Find ▸ to Scouting, to Compare pinned and a shortlist, and then into FM, where the deals are done or fall through. Three sales the plan never expected opened three more positions, and the squad count asked for two backups. Ten signings later, the window shuts.

The same save as part 1: Scouting across nine leagues, captured to 1 June 2027, and the window from June to 1 September.

Three parts · one case

  1. 1The diagnosisDeep enough?
  2. 2The rebuildThe summer window
  3. 3The verdictThe season

Ten screens · one window

  1. 1Right backTwo dials, three names
  2. 2Left wingA left foot, four names
  3. 3The no. 10Your own set cuts the strikers
  4. 4GoalLammens, on his last season
  5. 5In FMWhat the dials can't see
  6. 6The sumsA guide, not a quote
  7. 7New positionsThree sales the plan didn't see
  8. 8Left backFound outside the app
  9. 9Right wingEveryone wanted to start
  10. 10The windowTen in, seven out
  11. ✓RebuiltAnd what part 3 measures

?Where part 1 left it

Five positions, and a budget

Part 1 ended on a Transfer plan with five positions and no targets. Find ▸ on each card opens Scouting on that position, and the same routine runs for every one: pin the best on one dial, switch dial and pin again, then Compare pinned. Whoever falls short is taken out with ✕, and whoever is left goes on the shortlist.

Then the shortlist goes to FM, where scouts, agents, rival clubs and the board have their say.

The brief

First choice: a right back, then Dalot or Mazraoui goes. A left winger, then Rashford or Cunha goes.

Rotation: a backup no. 10 for Bruno, 32. A right winger better than Minteh, behind Mbeumo. A goalkeeper, if Lammens leaves.

Going out: Kim sold, Lacey on loan.

The money, in June: FM's budget was £51.79M to spend and £425K a week of wage room. The plan's first targets would come to far more, so the sales had to pay for the summer.

1Scouting · Compare pinned

Two dials, three names

Find ▸ on the Right Full Back card opens Scouting on full backs across nine leagues, already set for the position, with one filter added: right foot. 386 full backs are ranked, Ball winning first.

  • Ball winning cuts five. "I need a good ball winner, not necessarily Dalot levels but decent." Four crossers who can't defend go, and so does Mazraoui: 59, and 94th of 99 on key tackles. "Mazraoui is just not good enough, so he will be sold."
  • Crossing cuts four more: Sildillia, Bolla, Dest and Tomiyasu. Three are left, each a different answer.
  • Fisher is the only one good at both. 77 on Ball winning, 2nd of 99 on tackles. On the radar below, 43% of his crosses find a man, 1st of 76. He's 23, at Norwich, already in the Premier League.
  • Bronkhorst is the best crosser and the cheapest; he's also 30. Isaac crosses the most, 5.4 a game.
  • Part 1's question answered itself: Dalot, 95 on Ball winning and the best of the 386, stays.

Dalot's 95 on Ball winning here is 94 in part 1: Scouting ranks him among all nine leagues' full backs, League comparison among the Premier League's. In FM, Fisher's scouts gave him the only A on the list. His release clause set the price: £31M, above the app's £21M to £26M.

2Scouting · Compare pinned

A left foot, four names

For the left wing the filter is a left foot: "I play with a winger on the left side." Barcola, Cunha and Rashford are all right-footed, so the brief changes as well as the names. Chance creation first, then Crossing and Finishing.

  • Three are out before a figure counts. Saka, because Arsenal "would never sell to Man Utd". Yamal, at £246M and up. Bernardeschi, at 33.
  • Crossing added four, and Chance creation took them out. Burgering, Paredes, Daghim and Luvumbo cross well and create little: their shapes sit inside Barcola's. Karetsas, 19, went on Finishing, 147th.
  • Four are left, every shape filling Barcola's: Akliouche, Soulé, Olise and Akhomach.
  • FM settled it. Olise was "Doubtful" about moving, on £375K a week. Soulé was rated a Free Role player and moved to the no. 10 search. Akhomach beat Akliouche as the better crosser and finisher, at £43M.

Cunha and Rashford were pinned too. Rashford tops Chance creation on almost every figure, on 798 minutes. Both were sold: Cunha to Newcastle for £49M, his value, and Rashford to Sheffield United for £30M, above his. Together, £79M for Akhomach's £43M.

3Scouting · Your sets

Your own set cuts the strikers

Bruno is the only no. 10, at 32. The search for his backup ranks central midfielders on Chance creation and Finishing, then on a figure set of the user's own, Attacking Midfielders: key passes, expected assists, progressive passes, pass completion and possession lost.

  • Rivals are out first. Wirtz and Chiesa play for Liverpool, Cherki for Man City, Woltemade for Newcastle. Kramarić is 35, and Vitinha can't play there.
  • Finishing brought in four strikers in all but name. The set shows they don't create: Kostoulas is 135th of 138 on progressive passes, Raspadori 89th of 107. "Not enough forward passes trying to create opportunities for me."
  • Bruno himself is only 71 on the set. 2nd of 138 on key passes, but 94th on progressive passes and 95th on possession lost. He tries the hard pass and loses it.
  • The answer was Soulé, from the left-wing search: £55M up to £65M, after PSG came in for him, and on £190K a week. He scored two minutes into his debut.

Also pinned: Brahim Díaz, Pulisic, Karetsas, Baena, Panichelli, Esposito and Kvaratskhelia. Kostoulas went on the shortlist anyway, unpinned, as a striker: 20, and 85 to 96 on Finishing in a year.

4Scouting · Compare pinned

Lammens, on his last season

The goalkeeper card only counts if Lammens leaves. Scouting ranks 185 keepers on Shot stopping, and Compare pinned sets them against Vicario.

  • Lammens played 180 minutes, too few to rank. So his card shows the season before, the one part 1 called awful: typical 16, 25th of 25 on expected save percentage. It's the case for a No. 2 in one card.
  • Every new keeper pinned passes Vicario on goals prevented. Milinković-Savić is 1st of 23 in Serie A on four figures. Improving on Vicario, not just matching him, was possible.
  • Out: Mamardashvili, at Liverpool. Courtois, Leali and Mvogo, all over 30. Diogo Costa, at £68M and up.
  • FM's scouts agreed, B+ Superb, and Milinković-Savić was "happy to be backup to Vicario". £6M, up to £9.5M after 50 games, and his wage went down, to £75K.

Lammens went on Sell at £44M. He turned down every club that came, the offers fell each time, and the window shut with him in the U21s, valued at £8M.

5In FM

What the dials can't see

The dials made every shortlist. FM made the decisions, and they were almost never about a figure.

  • When the dials and the scouts agreed, it was quick. Fisher was the only A on his list, Milinković-Savić a B+, Soulé A+ "sign as a priority".
  • When they didn't, something else decided, and it was a different thing almost every time.

6Transfer plan · FM

A guide, not a quote

The plan's Buying and Wages tiles count each position's first target at his value and at the wage he's on now. The deals came in elsewhere.

  • Every wage but one went up, often by three or four times. Kaplan's went from £15.8K to £65K, Saibari's from £46K to £150K. Milinković-Savić took a cut to be No. 2.
  • Release clauses set three prices: Fisher at £31M, Saibari at £56M, and Álvarez at £30M, a clause never paid. A value shown as one figure, not a range, was the clue.
  • Selling, values fell the longer a player stayed listed. Mazraoui went from £33M to £15.5M before Real Hispalis paid it. Lammens fell from £44M to £8M and didn't go.

7Transfer plan

Three sales the plan didn't see

Part 1 found nothing to do at defensive midfield or left back, and Bruno had a year left. The window changed all three, and each sale opened a position of its own on the plan, waiting on the sale: "If Palhinha leaves", "If Shaw leaves", "If Fernandes leaves".

  • Palhinha. Everton offered £25.5M for a 31-year-old who'd played 738 minutes and cost £16M. "A no-brainer." The first Defensive Midfielder position is kept on the plan as Cancelled, with the reason. Hinshelwood signed: English, home-grown, £40M up to £45M, and the board's A+.
  • Shaw. He struggled in the first league game, at 32 and on £200K a week. A week later Mitchell, part 1's "ample cover", was player of the match. Shaw went to Roma for £28M, and Kharebashvili came in.
  • Bruno. "Considering his options", with a year left. FM won't offer a player over 30 more than a year, and not until December, and his mind was made up: sell now, or lose him free next summer. Atlético paid £31M; Saibari came in at his £56M clause.
  • And two backups the squad count asked for. "Four players for two positions means one injury away from struggling." Kaplan at centre back and Dias at defensive midfield, who can also drop back. The fans called Kaplan "surplus to requirements".

8In FM

Found outside the app

For Shaw's replacement the app came up short. The three young left backs its search found were all below him. The answer came from FM's own scouts, twice, and each one shows something the app can't see yet.

  • José Neto, 19, Benfica: six league games last season. FM's player search only filters on 0 or 10 games, so the capture takes 10, and a teenager breaking through never comes in. Benfica accepted £37M. He's parked for next summer.
  • Saba Kharebashvili, 18, Başakşehir: 83 senior games and 13 caps, in the Turkish Super League, which isn't among the nine leagues captured. Further on than Neto, the same potential, and less than half the price.
  • The capture is changing for FM27, which may close the first gap. The second is the leagues you choose to capture.

At Man Utd, Kharebashvili's value is already £31M to £38M. Against Mitchell he's level on mental and physical averages, ahead on passing and crossing, behind on tackling. Who starts by May is a question for part 3.

9Scouting · In FM

Everyone wanted to start

The right winger was meant to be rotation: better than Minteh, behind Mbeumo. Every player good enough to be better than Minteh wanted to start ahead of Mbeumo, and it took the whole window.

  • The season-by-season view changed a decision. Karetsas, cut twice on Finishing, was up a band on four dials at 19, so he went back on the shortlist. Bayern signed him for £53M first.
  • The plan closed once without a signing: "Promoted from within · Shea Lacey", the youth player part 1 meant to loan out.
  • Akliouche, from June's left-wing shortlist, filled it in the end, at £56M. He plays in the middle as well, which is what let Bruno go.

Gordon was the one the search agreed on: best on the dials, A+ in FM, English, and the only player the Champions League drew in. "He is worth it and would upgrade the team, but I don't think there is enough wiggle room in the budgets."

10Transfer plan · Progress

Ten in, seven out

The plan's Progress tab, as the window shut: every position with who filled it, every player gone and what his sale made room for.

  • £336.5M out and £206M in: £130.5M net.
  • £880.5K a week in and £1.44M out: a wage bill £554.5K a week lighter, with the two oldest and best paid, Bruno and Shaw, gone.
  • The fees mix two bases. Hinshelwood, Soulé and Dias show the most they can rise to, Milinković-Savić his fee before add-ons. All at the most, net spend is £134M; all before add-ons, £114.75M.
  • One sale is left: Lammens, in the U21s on £60K a week, after refusing every club.

1 September 2027, the window shut. During it, the case found four things the plan couldn't do, and the app changed: a player on loan in could be a target; two sales could make room for one signing; a youth player could fill a position, as Promoted from within; and this Progress tab, to follow the window to its last deal.

✓Rebuilt

Two deep, and younger

Every position now has a second player behind the first, and Lacey covers all three behind the striker. The squad is younger and costs £554.5K a week less to run. Whether it's deep enough for four competitions is what the season decides.

Rebuilt for four fronts

Bought: ten players, £336.5M. The five the brief asked for, three to replace sales nobody planned, and two backups for depth.

Sold: seven, £206M, and £1.44M a week of wages. Lammens is still for sale.

What the board expects: the Champions League league phase; Europa League places in the Premier League; the FA Cup quarter-finals; the Carabao Cup third round. The lowest bar on every front, below last season's 3rd place, cup semi-final and cup final.

So far: 1-1 with Brighton, Soulé scoring on his debut, and 1-0 at Wolves, Šeško scoring and Mitchell player of the match.

Part 3, the verdict, follows the season: the four targets, whether two deep was deep enough, who wins at left back, and whether Liverpool's squad really was "much stronger".

The screens it used

Scouting, then the Transfer plan

Find ▸ on a plan's card opens Scouting on that position across every league you capture. Compare pinned sets the players you pin side by side on radars, on any dial or on a figure set of your own. What you decide goes back on the Transfer plan, and Progress follows the window to its last deal.

Next in the case

Part 3, the verdict

The season: every one of the board's four targets met, from 13th at New Year, and where the summer's depth went.