Case files · case 1 · part 1 of 3

Underperforming

Part 1, the diagnosis. Man Utd finish 14th, with 43 points. Yet the Summary says the team led the league going forward. Six screens in Squad Vision, from the season's captures, show where it went: between the posts, and in the midfield in front of them.

A fresh save, separate from the season on the home page: Premier League 25/26, captured to 1 June 2026.

Three parts · one case

  1. 1The diagnosisWhy 14th?
  2. 2The rebuildThe summer window
  3. 3The verdictDid it work?

Six screens · the diagnosis

  1. 1The table14th, and no idea why
  2. 2SummaryAhead of the league, and behind it
  3. 3DefendingThe team's dial, opened
  4. 4All seasonGoals conceded, capture by capture
  5. 5The keeperOne player's dial, opened
  6. 6The midfieldA radar by position, opened
  7. ✓The diagnosisAnd the brief for the summer

1In FM · the final table

14th, and no idea why

The season ends with Man Utd 14th: 43 points from 38 games, 17 behind Leeds in 7th and 44 behind City. FM's table says how bad it was. It doesn't say why.

So: capture the last month, the league's players and its Team Stats page too, open Squad Vision's Summary, and see where the team stands against the rest of the league, figure by figure.

2Summary · Team

The best attack, and the leakiest goal

The Summary's Team tab answers half the question at once. It ranks the team among the league's 20 clubs on Football Manager's own team figures, from the 1 June team capture. Ahead of the league is long: first for dribbles and chances created, second for expected goals and shots. On most measures this was the best attack in the league. It didn't score its way to 14th.

Behind the league is short, and two of its three rows point at the same place: Conceded 16th and Clean Sheets 16th. Yellow cards, 20th, are worth a look another day. The goal is where to look now.

  • Every row is a link. Conceded opens its dial, Defending, so that's the one to click.
  • Expected Goals Against is on neither card. It's 12th, mid-table: the cards keep the top and bottom quarters, 1st to 5th and 16th to 20th. Remember it for the next screen.
  • Since last season stays quiet: it's a new save, with no season before 25/26 to compare against.

3League comparison · Teams · a dial opened

Average chances, too many goals

Clicking Conceded opens League comparison's Teams side on the Defending dial: typically 10th of 20. Every figure on it is Football Manager's own, for every club, from the league's Team Stats page. Most of the dial is mid-table or better. Its first wedge, Conceding, isn't.

  • Conceded, 1.82 a match, 16th. Hover it for the total: 69 in 38 games, against a league average of 1.40 a match.
  • Expected Goals Against, 1.43 a match, 12th. The chances the defence gave away were worth 54 goals over the season, a little worse than average. The team let in 69: fifteen more than the chances were worth.
  • Shots Against 7th, Shots on Target Against 13th. Fewer shots than most, but more of them on target. More reached the keeper than the shot count suggests, and too many of those went in.
  • Winning it back: Tackles Won 3rd, Interceptions 4th. Possession Won, 12th, is the one figure there in the middle. Screen 6 comes back to it.
  • Who makes up our conceded names nobody: it has no players' column in Settings, so the app won't split it between our players. The fifteen goals are a question for the Players side, after one more for the team's figure: the whole season, or a bad spell?

4League comparison · Teams · Season change

Bottom quarter all season, not one bad month

A bad spell would be a different problem from a bad keeper. Season change, on the same Teams side, sets Conceded against the league average at every team capture of the season.

  • Between 1.70 and 1.83 a match from the first capture to the last. The league average never rose above 1.41.
  • 15th in November, then 16th or 17th at every capture after. A team capture holds all 20 clubs, so every rank is of the whole league.
  • So it wasn't an injury or a dip in form. It was the whole season, and one keeper played all of it.

5League comparison · Players · a dial opened

One keeper, against every keeper

Pick Lammens on League comparison's Players side and open his Shot stopping dial. Now he's ranked against the Premier League's 26 goalkeepers with enough behind their figures, not against teams.

  • Save Percentage: 24th of 26, on 255 shots on target faced. That's not a small sample.
  • Expected Goals Prevented: 24th of 26, −13.2 over 44 full games. Thirteen goals worse than the shots he faced say an average keeper would have let in.
  • Expected Save Percentage: 26th of 26, the hardest shots of any keeper in the league. It's the defence's share of the blame, and it's real, but it's the smaller share.
  • Saves per 90: 9th of 26, better than 52 in 100. Busy, and saving plenty, just not enough of what came at him. It has no better end, so its slice is grey and it's never named his best.
  • Penalties Saved Ratio is left blank: 9 penalties faced, and ranking it needs 10. The app says so rather than rank him on too little.

6League comparison · Teams · a radar opened

The shots came through, but past whom?

The keeper is most of the answer. The rest is his Expected Save Percentage, 26th of 26: the hardest shots any keeper in the league faced, and more of them on target than most teams allowed, 13th on the Defending dial. So which line let them through? Radars on the Teams side, under By position, has a radar for each, built from the players' figures.

  • Defenders defending is top half on 5 of 6: 1st for tackles completed and interceptions, 7th for headers won. The back four win their duels. Fouls made, 20th, goes with the Summary's Yellow Cards, 20th, and is still one for another day.
  • Defensive midfield screen, one radar on, is top half on 1 of 7. Tackles 13th, and 17th for interceptions, possession won and pressures. The players there to stop an attack before it reaches the back four mostly don't.
  • Possession lost, 7th, is the one figure on the right side. They keep the ball well enough. They don't win it back.
  • What the radars can't say is where each shot came from. They point at the midfield. They don't prove it.

✓The diagnosis

Diagnosed

Five screens from the Summary on, and the season has an answer. The case isn't closed yet: what the summer did about it is part 2.

The attack was fine. The goal wasn't.

What went wrong: one goalkeeper played the season, and he was among the league's worst at stopping shots, from the first capture to the last. The team let in 69 league goals from chances worth 54. He was 24th of 26 on save percentage and −13.2 goals against expectation over 44 games. The defence made it harder, with the hardest shots in the league to save, but he fell well short even of those. And those shots look to have come through the middle: the back four won their duels, while the midfielders in front of them were 17th at winning the ball back.

What it didn't do: the attack wasn't the problem. Expected goals and chances created were near the top of the league.

The brief for the summer: a keeper first. Then a defensive midfielder who wins the ball back. The back four don't need replacing: they were 1st for tackles and interceptions. The screen in front of them was 17th on interceptions, possession won and pressures.

Part 2, the rebuild, follows the summer window that tried to fix it.

The screens it used

Summary, then League comparison

Every row on the Summary's league cards opens League comparison with its dial open large, on Football Manager's own team figures. Where a team figure can't be split between players, the Players side names who is behind it. That's the whole trail: a rank, a dial, a name.

Next in the case

Part 2, the rebuild

The summer window: a keeper, a midfield that wins the ball back, cover at the back and a striker, each picked on the figures, at home and abroad.