Case files · case 1 · part 3 of 3

Underperforming

Part 3, the verdict. A season after finishing 14th, with a new keeper, a new midfield and a new striker: did the rebuild work? Season review sets each signing beside the player before him and the season we bought him on, and says who moved the figures.

The same save: Premier League 26/27, captured to 1 June 2027, against 25/26 to 22 June 2026.

Three parts · one case

  1. 1The diagnosisWhy 14th?
  2. 2The rebuildThe summer window
  3. 3The verdictDid it work?

Eight screens · one season

  1. 1The table14th to 3rd
  2. 2The goalGoals conceded, two seasons
  3. 3VicarioBefore, bought on, for us
  4. 4The strikersŠeško and Suárez
  5. 5Who scored themConversion, broken down
  6. 6BalebaAgainst those he replaced
  7. 7The midfieldThe one not fixed
  8. 8MitchellShaw's deputy
  9. ✓Case closedWhat it all says

QuestionsFrom part 2, the rebuild

What the season had to answer

The summer brought in nine and sold ten, about £168M net at FM's listed fees. Each signing was bought on figures made somewhere else. Part 2 ended on five questions.

  • The keeper: the board graded Vicario C, the figures 93. Who was right?
  • The midfield: does a screen of Wharton, Baleba and Palhinha lift the three figures that were 17th?
  • The finishing: the team was 2nd on expected goals and 5th on goals. Does a finisher close the gap?
  • The league: do Diomande's and Suárez's figures from Portugal hold up in England?
  • The price: was selling Amad, our best chance creator, worth it?

1In FM · the final table

14th to 3rd

Man Utd finish 3rd on 83 points: 40 more than last season, and Champions League football. Three behind City, six behind the champions, Liverpool.

  • 93 scored, from 65: only Liverpool scored more.
  • 43 conceded, from 69: only Arsenal and Liverpool let in fewer. The swing is almost even at both ends.
  • And a cup: the Carabao Cup won, and an FA Cup semi-final lost to City.

2League comparison · Teams · Season change

The goal, fixed in the second half

Part 1 started with goals conceded, 16th all season. With both seasons ticked, Season change shows where this one went.

  • A bad first half: 1.47 a match at December, 13th, and 1.42 at January, 12th, barely better than the league's 1.39. The board's C for Vicario looked right.
  • Then it turned: 16 goals in the 19 games after New Year. By 1 June it was 1.13 a match, 3rd, behind only Arsenal and Liverpool.
  • The team's Defending dial went from typically 10th to 4th, and Clean Sheets from 16th to 3rd.
  • How much of that was the keeper a team figure can't say. Season review's Compare players can: Vicario is the next screen.

3Season review · compare players

Vicario: before, bought on, for us

Season review's compare players sets three seasons side by side, each player against that season's league players in his position: the player before, the season we bought him on, and his season for us.

  • Not the Spurs keeper: 1st of 26 on goals prevented there, 6th of 24 here. Behind our defence he faced different shots, and his figures settled lower.
  • Far better than the keeper before: Lammens was 23rd of 25 on save percentage and on goals prevented. Vicario is 7th and 6th, and 3rd on goals conceded.
  • So who was right? Neither, quite. The board's C was too low and the figures' 93 too high. The truth was in between, and enough to fix the goal.

4Season review · compare players

Two strikers who finish

The summer bought Suárez to finish what the team created. Set beside Šeško's two seasons, the finishing got better at both ends of the front line.

  • Suárez's figures travelled: 0.7 goals a match in Portugal and the same in England, converting 28% here, 3rd of 88, and 5.81 goals above expected.
  • Šeško doubled his: 0.4 a match last season, 0.8 this, with the league's best chances among strikers, 1st on expected goals, on 1,556 minutes.
  • Two kinds of striker: Šeško gets the best chances and scores what they're worth. Suárez scores well beyond his.

5Season review · League ranks

Who moved the conversion rate

Season review's League ranks takes one of the team's figures across both seasons and breaks the change down by position, then by player. Conversion rate went from 12%, 9th, to 15%, 1st: 3 points.

  • Ours is Football Manager's own figure. The positions and players under it are built from our players' own conversion rates in each season's league capture: the figure's players' column.
  • Strikers gave 1.4 of it, and Suárez alone 1.2. Šeško's own improvement added 0.5.
  • Wingers gave 0.4: Minteh, on loan, 0.2 of it. He scored 0.3 a match to Amad's 0.2, and above his chances where Amad was 1.66 goals below his.
  • 0.8 wasn't ours: the league's typical figures rose too. The view says so, and so should we.

The strikers opened; the wingers open the same way, Rashford, Minteh, Cunha, Barcola, Lacey and Mbeumo.

6Season review · compare players

Baleba, against the two he replaced

Casemiro and Ugarte went in the summer. Set beside them and his own Brighton season, Baleba is the ball-winner the brief asked for.

  • Better than both on every figure: pressing 5th of 101 where Casemiro was 85th; tackle ratio 77 to Casemiro's 61; possession won 28th to their 60th and 67th.
  • Better than his Brighton season on five of seven: tackle ratio up from 71 to 77, key tackles from 0.1 to 0.2, pressing from 7th to 5th.
  • Interceptions are the gap, 57th of 104, and the one figure all four are middling on.

7League comparison · Teams · a radar opened

The one part 1 screen not fixed

Part 1 found the midfield through this radar: top half on 1 of 7. A season on, it's top half on 2 of 7, and tackles and interceptions are 18th.

  • The team wins the ball: on the whole-team Ball winning radar, Football Manager's own figures, interceptions are 8th, possession won 8th and tackles won 5th. It's won by the defence and the full backs, by Mitchell 1st on tackles among full backs and Diomande 13th on interceptions among centre backs.
  • The position doesn't: the radar averages the defensive midfielders. Baleba did the job; Wharton was used box-to-box and the app now ranks him with central midfielders; Palhinha played too little.
  • The lesson: don't judge a fix by the one screen that found the problem. The table and the team figures say it worked; this radar says where to look next.

Part 1's ranks are added under each figure here, for the comparison; the app's own table shows this season's alone.

8Season review · compare players

Mitchell, Shaw's deputy

Mitchell was bought to close the drop behind Shaw: Dorgu, the backup before him, was 43rd of 122 full backs on Ball winning.

  • A far better defender than Dorgu: 1st of 118 on tackles, 7th on possession won, 4th on pressures, where Dorgu was 41st, 53rd and 8th.
  • Better than his Palace season too, on tackles, interceptions and possession won.
  • Not the crosser Palace had: 5.8 crosses a match to Palace's 9.4, playing behind a winger, and 14% completed to Dorgu's 21%. On the Crossing tab, the poor accuracy shows.

✓The verdict

Case closed

Three parts, two seasons, and the question from part 1 has its answer.

It worked, and not quite how it was planned.

The goal: fixed. Goals conceded 69 to 43, 16th to 3rd, and all of the turn after New Year. Vicario took half a season, then kept goal like the figures said he could, if not quite to his Spurs level.

The finishing: fixed, and more. Goals 65 to 93, conversion 9th to 1st. Suárez scored at the rate he had in Portugal, and Šeško doubled his beside him.

The midfield: the team wins the ball, the position still doesn't. Baleba did what he was bought for; Wharton found another job, box-to-box, and scored. The radar part 1 used is still the weak spot.

The rest: Diomande was the league's best centre back in the air, and his passing came good by the end. Mitchell was the deputy Shaw needed. Minteh covered Amad's goals, if not his chances.

The result: 14th to 3rd, the Carabao Cup, and an FA Cup semi-final. Next season brings Europe, and a game every three days. That's another question, and another case.

The screen it used

Season review

Every season set side by side: a figure broken down by who moved it, and each signing beside the player before him and the season we bought him on.

The case

From the start

Part 1 found the problem, part 2 rebuilt the squad, part 3 says whether it worked. Case 2, Four fronts, takes the same squad into Europe.