Case files · case 1 · part 2 of 3

Underperforming

Part 2, the rebuild. Part 1 found where 14th came from: a keeper among the league's worst, and a midfield that didn't win the ball back. This is the summer window that tried to fix it, from the brief to the last signing, each pick made on Squad Vision's figures.

The same save: Premier League 25/26, captured to 1 June 2026, and Football Manager's Player Database searched in June for players abroad. Fees are as FM lists them.

Three parts · one case

  1. 1The diagnosisWhy 14th?
  2. 2The rebuildThe summer window
  3. 3The verdictDid it work?

Nine screens · one summer

  1. 1By teamWhose goal is kept well
  2. 2Every keeperGoals prevented, in order
  3. 3VicarioHis dial, now he's ours
  4. 4The midfieldSix pinned, three of ours
  5. 5Wharton, BalebaTwo dials, one group
  6. 6Full backsThe drop behind the first choice
  7. 7Centre backsA Player Database search, two filters
  8. 8A strikerBetter than ours
  9. 9The windowNine in, ten out
  10. ✓Where it leaves usQuestions for part 3

BriefFrom part 1, the diagnosis

What the summer had to fix

Part 1 ended on a verdict, and the verdict is this part's brief. Everything that follows was bought, or sold, against it.

A keeper first. Then the ball back.

The keeper: Senne Lammens was 24th of 26 on save percentage and on goals prevented, −13.2 over 44 full games.

The midfield screen: 17th of 20 on interceptions, possession won and pressures, and 13th on tackles. Possession lost, 7th, was the one figure on the right side.

Leave the back four: 1st for tackles and interceptions. The depth behind them was another matter, as the summer found.

1League comparison · Teams · Table

Whose goal is kept well?

Start with teams, not keepers: League comparison's Teams side, Table, on the Stats page's Defending group, sorted on Conceded. Set each club's goals against its Expected Goals Against, two columns along. A club that lets in fewer than its chances were worth has a keeper earning his keep.

  • Five clubs let in well under their chances: Spurs 0.79 a match off 1.08 expected, Crystal Palace 1.18 off 1.44, Brentford 1.05 off 1.26, Sunderland 1.61 off 1.74 and Aston Villa 1.00 off 1.11.
  • Arsenal and Liverpool concede little, off little. 0.92 off 0.89, and 0.90 off 0.95: that's mostly their defences.
  • Bournemouth let in 1.39 off 1.40, level with their chances.
  • Ours: 1.82 off 1.43, the widest gap the wrong way in the league.
  • A team's row doesn't say who was in goal, or how many: Brentford's is two keepers. The next screen is the keepers themselves.

The top 16, down to ours; the four clubs below are cut.

2League comparison · Players · Leaders

One keeper on top, on enough shots

On the Players side, Leaders puts every keeper in the league in order on one figure. Sorted on Expected Goals Prevented, which allows for how hard each shot was, one name is clear.

  • Guglielmo Vicario, Spurs: 1st of 26, +0.3 a match, and 1st on save percentage too, 85%, on 248 shots on target faced.
  • Joint 2nd are Valdimarsson, Kelleher, Henderson and Roefs. Valdimarsson's 85% rests on 53 shots in 11 full games: too little to buy on. Henderson's 80% came off 299, the most near the top.
  • Petrović is 13th: level with what an average keeper would do, as Bournemouth's team row said.
  • Lammens is 24th. From top to ours is 0.6 of a goal a match.
  • There's no dial for Vicario yet: the app opens a dial only for a player at your club. Leaders is the screen for him until he signs.

The top 8 of 26, then Petrović and ours; the rows between are cut.

3League comparison · Players · a dial opened

Signed: 93 against 15

Spurs accepted £38M on 2 June, and Vicario signed on 16 June. Now he's ours his dial opens, on his figures for Spurs: typical 93, where Lammens' was 15, on the same dial against the same 26 keepers.

  • The same workload: both made 4 saves a match, 9th of 26. The difference is in what got past them.
  • Fair to Lammens: Vicario's expected save percentage is 88 and Lammens' 83, so Spurs' defence let through easier shots. Goals prevented allows for that, and still has Vicario 1st and Lammens 24th.
  • His weakest is still 2nd of 26: clean sheets, better than 83 in 100.
  • The board graded the signing C, on a 29-year-old's age and resale. The figures say 93. Part 3 asks who was right.

Lammens' dial is in part 1: the same seven slices, at 15.

4League comparison · Players · Leaders

Six pinned, three of ours

The midfield brief was winning the ball. Leaders on Ball winning, ranked against defensive midfielders, with six possibles pinned beside our three and the list sorted on possession won.

  • Wharton, Crystal Palace: top 20 on five of six. Pressures 5th, possession won 8th, tackles 13th, interceptions 15th. The all-rounder.
  • Baleba, Brighton, tackles 5th and presses 7th, but is 46th on interceptions. Palhinha, Spurs, wins it, 6th, and doesn't press, 73rd.
  • Hinshelwood is 1st on interceptions, on 844 minutes. Set aside: too little behind it.
  • Ours explain the radar: Casemiro 62nd, Ugarte 69th and Mainoo 82nd on possession won.
  • With the ball, on Passing and progression, our three were 60th to 77th on passes attempted, which is why possession lost looked good. Wharton loses it more, 78th, because he does more with it: 7th on progressive passes.

The six pinned and our three, from where they sit in the list; the top 20's other rows are cut.

5League comparison · Players · two dials opened

Signed: Wharton and Baleba

Palace accepted £75M for Wharton on 2 June, and Brighton £69M with add-ons for Baleba two days later. Both signed on 16 June, with Vicario. Here are their Ball winning dials, both ranked against the Premier League's 105 defensive midfielders.

  • Wharton, typical 83, is ahead of Baleba on everything but tackles: pressures 5th, possession won 8th, interceptions 15th. He reads it.
  • Baleba, typical 70: tackles 5th, pressures 7th, interceptions 46th. He goes and gets it.
  • Rank against matters. Set against central midfielders, Wharton's dial reads 86 among 167. Put both against the same group before setting them side by side.
  • FM's scouts gave both A+, "sign as a priority". The figures and the scouts picked the same two.
  • With Mainoo's pressing, 7th, they cover the three figures that were 17th. Palhinha came on 10 July for £16M as the fourth, once Casemiro and Ugarte had gone.

6League comparison · Players · Leaders

The drop behind the first choice

The brief said leave the back four, and for the first choices the figures agree. Leaders on Ball winning, ranked against the league's 122 full backs and ordered by Typical, has Dalot joint 1st and Shaw joint 3rd. The trouble is behind them.

  • On the right: Dalot 1st, then Mazraoui 12th. A fair backup.
  • On the left: Shaw 3rd, then Dorgu 43rd, red on interceptions. That's the gap.
  • Barbieri and Tchatchoua sit near the top on under 650 minutes each. Set aside.
  • Mitchell is 9th, and going forward 10th on chance creation and 17th on crossing. Robinson, 6th here, is 61st and 69th on those. Livramento, 5th, was over £80M. Mitchell signed on 24 June for £48M, and Dorgu went to Sporting for £29M.
  • Dalot stayed, so the right side was left as it was.

The top 13 and Dorgu, 43rd; the rows between are cut. Pressures Attempted per 90 is further along, as the table scrolls.

7Scouting · Player Database, then Scout

The fifth centre back, found abroad

Maguire and Martínez left, and the backups behind Kim and de Ligt had barely played: Yoro 468 minutes, and Heaven a season on loan in the Championship. So the search went abroad. Leaders only covers leagues a club of ours plays in, so it went to Football Manager's Player Database instead: centre backs with 10 league games or more, worth up to £70M, in five leagues. Capture, on Scouting's Player Database tab, read the 397 it found. On Scout, with that import picked under Where from, two metric filters, Headers Won per 90 at least 4 and Headers Won Percentage at least 75, leave 38.

  • Diomande, Sporting CP, is 1 of 38 on pass completion, 94%, and 2 of 38 on possessions lost, 2.0 a match. He's level with de Ligt in the air.
  • Gąsiorowski, PSV, is like for like with de Ligt, for about £40M.
  • Branthwaite, Everton, is 2 of 38 on headers won but 25 of 38 on pass completion. A specialist.
  • Each rank is among the 38 in the import, from five leagues together, and Diomande's figures were earned in Portugal. Whether they hold in England is a question for part 3.
  • The import isn't kept, so the three went on a Centre backs shortlist in Football Manager, and Capture on Scouting's Football Manager shortlists tab kept their figures. He signed on 26 July for his £69M release clause: the all-rounder at 22, over the specialist.

Four of the top eight on passing, and Branthwaite for the contrast; the rows between are cut. Our own players are never in Scout: de Ligt and Kim are set against the league on League comparison.

8League comparison · Leaders, then Scout

A striker better than ours

Zirkzee, the backup striker, was more a deep-lying forward than a finisher, so he went to RB Leipzig for £34.5M. The search for his replacement started at home and found a bigger problem: on League comparison's Leaders, on Finishing, our own forwards sit a long way down the Premier League.

  • Šeško, the first choice, is 30th of 75 strikers on goals per 90, 0.4 a match, and the rest of ours are further down.
  • So it wasn't a backup we needed, but a striker better than our starter. Part 1 had the team 2nd on expected goals and 5th on goals: chances made, not taken.
  • Then abroad, on Scout: a Player Database search for strikers with 10 league games or more in the same five leagues read 384, and Goals per 90 at least 0.6, half again Šeško's, leaves 21.
  • Ekitiké of Liverpool tops it, 0.9 a match, but Liverpool's first choice wasn't for sale. Dany Mota of Genk converts 24%, 1 of 21, for about £12M, but on 1,198 minutes, and he'd only just joined Genk.
  • Luis Suárez of Sporting CP scored 0.7 a match on 3,721 minutes, 4 of 21. He went on a Strikers shortlist in Football Manager, captured before the bid, so his Sporting season is kept. At £69M he came after the centre back, and Amad was sold to Barcelona for £44M to pay for him.
  • He signed on 5 August. Minteh came on loan from Brighton to cover the right, Amad's side.

The top six of 21 on goals per 90. Suárez is the volume: 2.1 shots on target a match, 2 of 21, over a full season.

9In FM · the window

Nine in, ten out

Everything the window did, from FM's messages, at the fee each one gives. Add-ons, agents' cuts and solidarity payments move the totals a little. They don't change the shape.

  • About £386M in and £218M out: about £168M net.
  • Zirkzee, Sancho and Bayındır were trimming. Amad was a real sacrifice: our best chance creator, sold to pay for a finisher.
  • Johnstone was signed as a home-grown third keeper, not on the figures. Minteh is on loan to the end of the season.

✓Where it leaves us

Rebuilt, not yet proven

The window closed with the season under way. Every signing was bought on figures made somewhere else, and only a season in our shirt will say whether they travel.

The brief, answered on paper.

What it fixed, on the figures: a keeper 1st of 26 on goals prevented, where ours was 24th. Three ball-winners for a midfield screen that was 17th. Cover behind Shaw and the centre backs. And a striker 4th of 262, where ours was 124th.

What it cost: about £168M net, and Amad.

What part 3 asks: was the board's C for Vicario right, or the figures' 93? Do Diomande's and Suárez's figures from Portugal hold up in England? Does the midfield lift the three figures that were 17th? Do the goals catch up with the expected goals? And was Amad worth it?

Part 3, the verdict, follows the 26/27 season and says whether it worked.

The screens it used

Leaders on League comparison, and Scout

One figure, the whole league in order, with the players you're weighing up pinned beside your own. For players abroad, Scouting's Scout searches your Football Manager shortlists and a Player Database import, filters to the players who clear your bar, and puts them on the shortlist.

Next in the case

Part 3, the verdict

14th to 3rd and a cup: each signing set beside the player before him and the season we bought him on.